Mexican restaurant and bar · Wyckoff, New Jersey, United States

Blue Moon Mexican Cafe

Full-service Mexican restaurant and bar in Wyckoff, NJ, serving lunch, brunch and dinner, with a scratch kitchen, craft margaritas, catering and live events.

About Blue Moon Mexican Cafe

A neighborhood Mexican restaurant in Wyckoff

Blue Moon Mexican Cafe is a full-service Mexican restaurant and bar in the Boulder Run Shopping Center in Wyckoff, New Jersey. The kitchen serves lunch, brunch and dinner, and the bar pours craft margaritas, sangria, beer and cocktails. The bar stays open later than the kitchen.

The restaurant describes its cooking as done in-house in a scratch kitchen, with nothing frozen and no shortcuts. Its menu is built around burritos, fajitas, tacos, margaritas and sangria, alongside seasonal specials. Separate menus cover dinner, lunch, drinks, a kids' menu, happy hour and a gluten "safe" and vegan-friendly selection.

From Manhattan to Bergen County

The first Blue Moon Mexican Cafe opened in Manhattan's Chelsea section in 1987, founded by Howard Felixbrod with his brother Gary and New York Rangers hockey player George McPhee. A second Manhattan location on the Upper East Side followed, backed by other professional hockey players. After Felixbrod moved to Bergen County, the group opened Blue Moon Englewood in 1995.

In February 2000 the company opened a strip-mall location without a liquor license in Wyckoff, which built a strong take-out business and a family clientele. In 2011 the Wyckoff restaurant doubled in size and added a bar area. Further locations opened in Woodcliff Lake, New Jersey, and Bronxville, New York. Felixbrod later sold all locations except Wyckoff, and with partner Colleen Grennan the business has concentrated on adding the Blue Moon Catering Marketplace.

Menus and specials

  • Dinner, lunch and brunch menus, plus a kids' menu.
  • Drinks menu covering craft margaritas, sangria, beer and cocktails.
  • Happy hour menu, with Fiesta Hour in the bar area Monday through Friday from 3pm to 6pm.
  • Gluten "safe" and vegan-friendly menu.
  • Seasonal specials alongside the regular lineup of burritos, fajitas and tacos.

Ordering, catering and events

Local pick-up and delivery orders run through the Wyckoff restaurant location. Catering is offered both for businesses and for homes. Through the Blue Moon Catering Marketplace, the company serves Mexican food to homes, businesses and doctors' offices and partners with other local restaurants to offer clients Italian, deli, Chinese and other cuisines.

The Wyckoff location hosts live music and events, including Fiesta Hour, Ladies Night, trivia nights and dueling pianos. The team also handles private gatherings such as birthday parties, graduations and other celebrations.

Visiting and reservations

Reservations are recommended for weekends, special events and parties of six or more; walk-ins are welcome but may face a wait at peak times. Reservations are not accepted on Cinco de Mayo, when guests can call ahead or join the waitlist online. The restaurant provides high chairs and a kids' menu and has been recognized locally as a family-friendly restaurant. Gift cards can be bought online or in person, and a Blue Bucks loyalty program earns rewards with each visit.

In brief

Mexican food, margaritas and catering

Photos

Select a photo to enlarge it.