Bullymake

Bullymake: dog toy and treat subscription for power chewers

Bullymake is a company that offers a monthly subscription box with dog toys and treats. Its focus is on dogs with strong or aggressive chewing habits, for which it provides highly durable toys. The company states that its nylon and rubber toys, as well as all of its treats, are made in the USA.

Types of toys by chew style

Bullymake's catalog organizes toys by durability and the dog's play style. Each category is designed for a specific type of pet.

• Nylon (Ultra Chewer): described as the toughest in the lineup, designed for dogs with extremely strong jaws. According to the company, it withstands over 3500 PSI, maintains its shape, and features grooves for spreads. Made in the USA.
• Rubber (Power Chewer): tough yet somewhat flexible toys that are bouncy and durable. They can hold treats inside, are great for fetch, and are scented to stimulate the sense of smell. Made in the USA.
• Rope (Interactive Play): a 100% cotton rope toy with thick braiding, designed for interactive tug play and to withstand strong pulling.
• Ballistic (Interactive Play): made with durable fabric and a crinkly interior, it is intended for tug and roughhousing, not for chewing. The outer material is soft and gentle on teeth and gums.
• Plush (Soft Chewer): the softest option, for light chewers and cuddling. It includes a squeaker to add excitement, though the company itself warns it can be destroyed.

Treats and options for dogs with allergies

The box includes treats made with intensely flavored proteins. The company states that its treats are made in the USA and can be customized to accommodate various types of allergies. The selection can be grain-free and chicken-free, and customers can configure the box to keep mealtime safe and appealing for their dog.

Box contents and how it works

Each monthly Bullymake shipment includes two to three guaranteed tough toys and three healthy treats. The boxes follow a different theme each month. The subscription process consists of four steps: the customer provides their dog's weight, allergies, and toy preferences; chooses a plan; customizes the box with the toy types that match the dog's play style; and receives the order monthly. The company offers 1, 3, 6, or 12-month plans, with discounts of up to 20% for longer-term plans. Shipments go out the day after subscribing and every 30 days thereafter.

Safety and materials

Bullymake maintains that its rubber and nylon toys are FDA food-grade safe, free of BPA, lead, and phthalates, and contain only natural additives. The company states that these toys withstand over 3500 PSI, four times the force of the strongest dog bite. It adds that its nylon and rubber toys have been tested by subscribers.

Guarantee and positioning

The company offers a 100% durability guarantee and states that over one million dogs use its products. In its comparison with other dog subscription services, Bullymake highlights the American manufacturing of its toughest toys and all of its treats, the use of non-toxic, phthalate-free, FDA-approved materials, complete box customization, five items per monthly box, the durability guarantee, scented and treat-dispensing chews, and shipping in a box for easier unboxing.

Subscription options and monthly themes

The service allows you to choose between a mix of toys and treats, toys only, or combine soft puppy toys with tough chew toys for dogs in the same box. The company presents the subscription as a gift option for dogs of all sizes and chew styles. The monthly themes shown on the site include the Superhero box (September 2026), the Backyard BBQ box (August 2026), and the Game Night box (July 2026). The site also advertises a first box for $19 with free poop bags.