Best NY Pizza
Family-owned Tampa pizzeria serving hand-tossed, stone-fired New York-style and Sicilian pizza since 2005, with dine-in, pickup and delivery.
About Best NY Pizza
A Brooklyn-rooted pizzeria in Carrollwood
Best NY Pizza is a family-owned pizzeria founded in 2005 by Brooklyn natives Greg and Pat, who brought their family's New York pizza recipes and techniques to Tampa Bay. The Carrollwood shop on North Dale Mabry Highway is one of two locations, alongside a Wesley Chapel branch, and both share the same menu and hours. The kitchen makes its dough and sauce from scratch daily and bakes pies in stone deck ovens.
The New York-style approach
The crust is the focus: dough is hand-stretched daily without rolling pins or presses, given a 48-hour cold proof, and made with imported high-gluten flour. Pizzas bake hot and fast on stone to produce a thin, crisp bottom with a chewy, foldable interior. The house describes using high-quality mozzarella and a signature NY tomato sauce.
Pizza styles and sizes
- Stone-fired NY cheese pizza: thin, foldable crust with bubbling cheese and bright tomato sauce, the most popular order.
- Sicilian pizza: thick, airy crumb with caramelized cheese edges and a hearty layer of tomato and mozzarella.
- Pepperoni: cup-and-char pepperoni with crispy edges and melted mozzarella on a foldable NY crust.
Pizzas range from 10 to 18 inches; a 16-inch pie typically feeds three to four people and an 18-inch feeds four to five. Sizes include personal, medium, large, family and Sicilian. Gluten-free dough is available for all pizza varieties in personal size only.
Beyond pizza
The menu extends to calzones, strombolis, chicken rolls, meatball sliders, hot subs such as the Philly cheesesteak, Buffalo wings, antipasto salad, and Italian dinners including spaghetti and meatballs, ravioli, chicken parm and lasagna, plus appetizers and desserts. The shop notes it is the only NY pizza shop in the area offering slices, Sicilian, wings, pasta and catering together.
Ordering and service
Customers can dine in at casual seating, order for pickup or request delivery through the online ordering system. Most pickup orders are ready in about 15 to 25 minutes, while delivery times depend on distance and demand and are confirmed at checkout. The pizzeria describes its crust and toppings as built to travel well for takeout and delivery. Published prices for NY-style pizza run roughly $10 to $20.
Delivery area from Carrollwood
The Carrollwood location serves the heart of Carrollwood and nearby communities including Northdale, Citrus Park, Westchase, Greater Carrollwood, Lake Magdalene, Town 'n' Country, University Area, Temple Terrace and Keystone.
Recognition and holiday hours
The pizzeria has been named "Best Pizza in Tampa" by Creative Loafing and "Best Pizza in Tampa Bay" by the Tampa Bay Times, and has received a Nextdoor Neighborhood Fave distinction. Holiday hours are posted separately from regular service: closed Thanksgiving and Christmas Day, open 11am to 8pm on Christmas Eve and New Year's Eve, and open at 12pm on New Year's Day.
New York-style and Sicilian pizza