
Casa Ninos Pizza Bar
Family-owned Staten Island pizzeria since 1997, serving hand-tossed NY-style and wood-fired pizza, Italian entrees, catering trays and a private party room for up to 50.
About Casa Ninos Pizza Bar
A South Shore pizzeria since 1997
Casa Ninos Pizza Bar is a family-owned Italian restaurant and pizzeria on Arthur Kill Road, in Staten Island's South Shore. It has operated since 1997, preparing hand-tossed New York-style pies in high-temperature stone ovens with fresh ingredients, local cheeses and simmered plum marinara sauce. The kitchen also turns out traditional Italian cooking, from hand-rolled pastas to seafood, and the dining room seats up to 50 people and serves wine and beer.
Service covers dine-in, takeout, delivery and catering. Delivery runs daily to Arden Heights, Rossville, Eltingville, Great Kills, Annadale, Pleasant Plains, Charleston and Huguenot, and minimum delivery charges may apply. The restaurant also welcomes corporate and school accounts.
Pizzas and toppings
The core of the menu is the classic round pie, available as a 12-inch personal ($15) or 16-inch large ($17). The Sicilian is a thick-crust, crisp rectangular pan pizza sold as a 16-inch square for $22. The white pie combines ricotta, creamy mozzarella, garlic and Italian herbs, at $19 personal and $25 large. A gluten-free cheese pizza, described as coeliac-friendly, comes only in a 12-inch personal size for $15.
Traditional toppings can be added at $4.25 for a half and $7.25 for a whole pizza: broccoli, extra cheese, spinach, roasted peppers, bacon, jalapeño peppers, garlic, meatballs, mushrooms, olives, peppers, onions, pepperoni, sausages and anchovies. Gourmet toppings — breaded chicken cutlets, eggplant and sautéed broccoli rabe — cost $5 half and $10 whole.
Specialty pies include the Buffalo Chicken (spicy glazed buffalo chicken and mozzarella, $22 personal / $27 large), the Chicken Caesar (baked crust topped with cold romaine, seasoned chicken and Caesar dressing, $25 / $30), the Margherita (plum tomatoes, fresh mozzarella medallions, extra virgin olive oil and basil, $19 / $25) and a Vodka Pizza with creamy pink vodka sauce.
Everyday deals and lunch
The restaurant publishes a set of value combinations, stated as valid for the whole of 2026 and requiring no coupon:
- The Crazy 8 Special ($31.88): eight traditional New York slices from a medium cheese pie, eight crispy wings, eight garlic knots and eight mozzarella sticks.
- The Real Deal ($27.00): two medium hand-tossed cheese pies, ten garlic knots and a two-liter soda.
- 2 Pizza Deal ($25.00): one large round pizza plus a square traditional cheese pizza.
- Half-tray Chicken Francese ($35.00): chicken Francese over ziti with a focaccia bread; a bottle of wine can be added for $19.95.
Lunch specials run from 11am to 3pm for dine-in or takeout, each priced at $10.95: personal cheese pizza, penne vodka, bacon cheeseburger with fries, a pick-two of hero and half salad, ravioli marinara or alfredo, and homemade manicotti.
Catering and the party room
Catering has been part of the business since 1997, covering weddings, sweet sixteens, graduations, corporate luncheons and family gatherings. Half trays feed 6 to 8 people and full trays 12 to 15; the kitchen also makes oversized custom heroes. Trays are delivered hot across the same South Shore neighborhoods. The vodka sauce is made with prosciutto di Parma. A portion calculator on the site estimates how many trays a given guest count requires, suggesting about three half trays or two full trays for a group.
The private dining space on Arthur Kill Road hosts baptisms, communions, confirmations, graduations, milestone birthdays and baby showers for up to 50 guests, with no room rental fee. It offers custom buffet menus, family-style Italian packages and an optional wine and draft bar.
Other menu sections and practical notes
Beyond pizza, the menu is organized into rolls and calzones, heroes and burgers, starters and salads, pasta and entrees, and desserts and drinks. A four-course dine-in dinner is offered at $25 per person family style, with baked clams, penne pomodoro, a choice of chicken Francese or eggplant parm, and cannoli with coffee. Customers can order online for pickup or delivery, and the restaurant runs a VIP text club advertising weekly specials and coupon codes.
New York-style and wood-fired pizza, Italian catering
Photos
Select a photo to enlarge it.



