Williams & Case Insurance Agency

Williams & Case Insurance Agency: Independent Insurance Brokerage in Sebring, Ohio

Williams & Case Insurance Agency is a third-generation, family-owned independent insurance agency headquartered in Sebring, Ohio. Founded in 1946, the firm operates as an independent broker: it compares coverage options across different insurers to tailor customized policies rather than offering a single product from one company.

Its focus is on personal, commercial, and farm insurance, with coverage for Northeast Ohio and Western Pennsylvania. The agency operates from its Sebring office and serves both individuals and businesses in the region.

Personal Insurance Products

The personal insurance portfolio includes coverage for homeowners, auto, renters, landlords, recreational vehicles, and powersports, as well as personal umbrella policies to extend liability. It also offers specialized farm insurance for local operations.

Solutions for Businesses and Farms

For businesses, the agency offers commercial general liability, commercial property insurance, business owners policies (BOP), commercial auto insurance, workers' compensation coverage, and employers' liability. In the farm sector, it designs protections for livestock, crops, farm machinery, and farm liability.

Clients We Serve

The agency describes several client profiles: homeowners and families seeking property, auto, and umbrella insurance; small businesses and contractors, with coverage for offices, retail shops, construction sites, and independent professionals; farms and livestock operations; manufacturers and commercial properties needing to protect heavy equipment, inventory, general liability, and employees; and new residents or families moving to the area who need local policies quickly.

Geographic Coverage and Local Markets

Williams & Case serves Northeast Ohio and Western Pennsylvania. Among the locations it mentions are Sebring, Alliance, Salem, Canfield, Boardman, Youngstown, Beloit, Canton, Lisbon, Carrollton, Akron, and Cleveland. The agency notes that its local knowledge covers seasonal weather risks, regional property values, local business regulations, and driving conditions specific to the area.

Team and Licensing

James (Jim) Williams serves as agency president. Grandson of co-founder Gail W. Williams, he joined in 2000 before graduating from Mount Union College (now University of Mount Union) in Alliance, Ohio. He is licensed in Ohio, Pennsylvania, Indiana, and Florida for various property, casualty, life, and health coverages.

Julie Anderson is office manager and a licensed agent in Ohio; she joined in 2018. Kylie McLean, a licensed agent in Ohio, joined the team in 2024 and is a graduate of The Ohio State University. Katie Shaffer, also a licensed agent in Ohio, came on board in late 2022 from Florida. The agency states that the entire team can handle inquiries, issue quotes, and manage policy changes.

Memberships and Approach

The firm is an active member of the Alliance Area Chamber of Commerce, Ohio Insurance Agents, and Trusted Choice. Its approach includes comparing coverage across insurers, providing personalized recommendations, and conducting periodic policy reviews to adjust protection.

Contact and Hours

Phone service is available at (330) 938-6123. Regular hours are Monday through Friday from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., closed Saturdays and Sundays; the agency notes that other times can be arranged by appointment. Quotes can be requested by phone or through its website.

Location and Contact

60 South 15th Street PO Box 159 Sebring, Ohio 44672 · Phone: 330-938-6123 · Hours: Mon-Fri: 8am – 5pm Sat-Sun: Closed