Massey Insurance Agency

Massey Insurance Agency is an independent Newark firm whose official website says it was founded in 1975 and offers personal auto, home and commercial insurance. The Newark office is at 46 Lyons Avenue, Newark, NJ 07112; its published number is (973) 926-6300. The agency says it has been included in an NJBIZ Top 50 insurance-brokerage list, a company-reported recognition rather than a current ranking independently established here.

There is a stronger state-record detail to check: the New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance’s Essex County list names Massey Agency Inc at this same address and phone as a producer for the New Jersey Personal Automobile Insurance Plan, the state’s assigned-risk market. That credential means it is on the state’s contact list for applications to that plan; it does not say the firm is an insurer, guarantee a quote or claim, or establish which voluntary-market carriers it represents. People who have been unable to obtain ordinary-market coverage can ask about PAIP; every shopper should ask the agency which standard-market insurers it currently represents and compare quotes. NJDOBI also provides an official live search for a specific producer’s current license, though its linked search returned an access error during this review. Ask for the individual producer’s name and license number and confirm it through the state lookup or DOBI before binding coverage.

Google Maps, opened directly on September 28, 2026, showed 4.1 out of 5 from 21 reviews for the 46 Lyons Avenue location. The visible review summaries praise customer service and staff friendliness, while one recent review reports an unanswered follow-up in a tax-preparation matter. The review labels include taxes and friendliness, and the visible comments are not specific to auto insurance. The overall score therefore should not be read as a rating of a particular policy or insurer; the sample is also small and can change.

The official location page lists weekday hours as Monday through Friday, 9 a.m.–5 p.m., and says the office is closed on weekends. It links the agency’s Facebook and LinkedIn pages. The official site hosts the agency logo. Call ahead to confirm the office schedule and ask whether the person who will handle the quote holds an active New Jersey property-and-casualty producer license. This is a documented local option to compare, not a guarantee that its coverage, rates or service will suit every driver.

Google review excerpts: Google Maps review highlights mention friendly staff and customer service; a recent review raises a delay in follow-up on a tax-preparation service. Visible comments are not a review of a particular auto policy.

Sources: Massey Insurance Agency | official website · Meet Us | Massey Insurance Agency · Newark Office | Massey Insurance Agency · Essex County PAIP Producers | New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance · Insurance Licensing and Education | NJDOBI · Insurance Producer Lookup | NAIC external lookup linked by NJDOBI · Google Maps: Massey Insurance Agency