Neapolitan pizzeria · Montclair, New Jersey, United States

Bivio Pizza Napoletana

Neapolitan pizzeria in Montclair, NJ, serving wood-fired pies made with Italian 00 flour, San Marzano tomatoes and a long-fermented natural yeast culture.

About Bivio Pizza Napoletana

A small Neapolitan pizzeria on Pine Street

Bivio Pizza Napoletana is a compact pizzeria in Montclair, New Jersey, focused on traditional Neapolitan pizza. The dining room seats 24, and the menu is deliberately short: five composed pizzas plus two specials. The restaurant does not offer takeout, takeaway or delivery, and it is BYOB.

Dough, oven and ingredients

The dough is built on Italian “00” flour from Naples and a natural yeast culture the owners call “la bambina,” described as a 27-year-old lievito madre. It is mixed slowly in a spiral mixer and left to ferment before baking. Pizzas go into a custom-made wood-burning oven for about 90 seconds at intense heat.

The toppings follow Neapolitan tradition: San Marzano tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, fresh basil, fior di latte or bufala mozzarella and sea salt. The kitchen also uses ingredients imported from Italy alongside fresh local produce, and the fresh mozzarella is made daily.

The pizzas

The menu centers on classic styles rather than an extensive list. Reported pies include marinara, margherita, white bianca and porcini mushroom, along with rotating specials. One frequently mentioned special pairs paper-thin slices of sweet lemon with soppressata. The owner has said he will adjust a pie when a diner wants an ingredient such as garlic removed.

Reservations and house rules

Seating is limited, so reservations are handled through OpenTable. Guests are asked to give 24 hours' notice of any change to a reservation time to avoid fees. Depending on availability, parties of two may be seated at the chef counter or at a table. Highchairs are not available, which families with young children should keep in mind.

Private events

A private dining room accommodates up to 24 guests for intimate gatherings, business meetings and celebrations. An event coordinator works with hosts on a customized menu and the details of the event.

Background

Owner Tommaso Colao, a Paterson native and jazz musician, opened the original Bivio in Little Falls in June 2011 with his wife Jackie after four years of practicing pizza at home. That restaurant closed in 2015, and the couple reopened in Montclair in December, making pizza and salads only. The Montclair restaurant later announced a closure dated September 27, 2022, and subsequently announced a soft reopening on January 19 and 20, 2024, under new owner Davide, with chef Tommaso reorganizing the kitchen. A later update states the restaurant has reopened, serving Thursday, Friday and Saturday from 5:00 to 10:00 PM by reservation only through OpenTable.

Recognition

Local food writers have highlighted Bivio as one of the area's better Neapolitan pizzerias, and the restaurant has been featured in Bobbi Brown's blog, which noted the 950-degree brick oven and Italian-imported ingredients.

In brief

Neapolitan wood-fired pizza