Pizzeria & Italian restaurant · Greece, New York, United States

Cinelli's Pizza & Italian Kitchen

NY-style pizza, Italian dinners, wings, calzones and subs in Greece, NY, with full vegan and gluten-free menus plus catering across Rochester.

About Cinelli's Pizza & Italian Kitchen

NY-style pizza and Italian cooking in Greece, NY

Cinelli's Pizza & Italian Kitchen serves hand-tossed New York-style pies, slices and sheet pizzas alongside Italian dinners, wings, calzones and hot subs at 741 Maiden Ln in Tops Plaza, Greece, NY. The kitchen traces its recipes to Josephine Cinelli, who began working at the original Cinelli's Restaurant in 1956; the current location presents those family recipes as its foundation.

Orders can be placed online for pickup or delivery, though delivery is handled through the restaurant's own website only. Phone orders are pickup only. The restaurant also runs a full vegan menu and a full gluten-free menu, each with its own pizzas, dinners and subs.

The main menu

Appetizers and salads

  • Mozzarella Sticks $10.50; Chicken Parm Bites $13.50; Eggplant Tower $14.00; House Made Potato Skins $12.00; Garlic Bread $7.50 (add cheese +$1.50)
  • Salads: Side $6.00, Garden $12.00, Antipasto $15.00, Chicken Wing $15.00, Philly Style Steak $16.00, Italian with Grilled Chicken $15.00, The Pizza Salad $15.00

NY-style pizza

Classic pies are priced by size (small, medium, large): Cheese $11.00/$17.00/$20.00, one topping $12.00/$19.00/$23.00, two toppings $13.00/$21.00/$26.00, three toppings $14.00/$23.00/$28.00, with extra toppings at $1.00/$2.00/$3.00 per topping. Sheet party pizzas run $30.00 for cheese, $34.00 with one topping and $38.00 with two.

Specialty pizzas, also by size, include Chicken Wing, Alexis Pepperoni Lover, Meat Lover, Cinelli's Ricotta Pie, Dill Pickle and White Pepperoni at $14.00/$21.00/$26.00, and Supreme and Veggie at $15.00/$22.00/$27.00. Featured specialty pies add White Artichoke and Spinach, The Breakfast, The Philly, Cinelli's Classic Meatball Pie, Eggplant Rollatini, Chicken Parm and Waist Watcher (no mozzarella).

Wings, combos and baskets

  • Chicken wings: 5 pieces $8.00, 10 pieces $15.00, 15 pieces $18.00, 25 pieces $30.00; boneless wings (10 oz) $15.00; house-made cauliflower wings $15.00
  • Combos: medium one-topping pizza with 10 wings $28.00; large one-topping pizza with 15 wings $35.00; sheet one-topping pizza with 25 wings $60.00; two large one-topping pizzas with 15 wings $60.00; 50 wings $60.00; 100 wings $110.00
  • Baskets, all with fries: chicken fingers $15.00, chicken wings (5 pcs) $14.00, cauliflower wings $16.00, mozzarella sticks $14.00

Pasta and Italian entrees

Pasta dishes include Spaghetti Marinara $12.00, Spaghetti with Meatballs or Sausage Links $16.00, Gnocchi Marinara $14.00, Baked Cheese Ravioli $13.00, Baked Rigatoni and Ricotta $15.50, Fettuccine Alfredo $14.00, Spicy Cinelli $15.00, Pasta Primavera $15.50 and Pasta with Garlic, Oil and Broccoli $13.00. Meatballs or sausage links can be added for $4, and grilled chicken to the Alfredo for $4. A side salad can be added to any pasta or Italian entrée for $5.

Italian entrées cover Chicken Riggies $17.00, Chicken Parmesan with Spaghetti $16.00, Chicken Parmesan with Fettuccine Alfredo $20.00, Eggplant Parmesan with Spaghetti $16.00, Fettuccine with Sausage, Peppers and Onion $16.00, Eggplant Rollatini with Rigatoni $16.00 and Pasta alla Eggplant $16.00.

Calzones, stromboli and hot subs

Calzones and stromboli include Cheese Calzone $10.50, Pepperoni Stromboli $11.50, Cinelli's Ricotta Pie Calzone $15.50, Meat Lover Calzone $15.50, Supreme Calzone $16.00, Chicken Wing Stromboli $15.50, The Philly Steak Stromboli $16.00 and The Breakfast Stromboli $16.00, with extra toppings at $1.50.

Hot subs come in small and large sizes: Southern Fried Chicken, Chicken Wing, Philly Style Steak, The Breakfast, Meatball Parm, Chicken Parm, Eggplant Parm and Italian Sausage, Peppers and Onion at $10.50/$15.50, and The Big Steak and Cheese at $12.50/$17.50. Mayonnaise, lettuce and tomato can be added to any sub.

Vegan menu

The vegan kitchen mirrors the main menu with its own pricing. Vegan appetizers include chicken fingers and fries $17.00, eggplant tower $15.00, potato skins $14.00, garlic bread $7.50 (vegan mozzarella +$2) and cauliflower wings $15.00. Vegan salads run from a $6.00 side to a $17.00 Buffalo chicken wing salad, with vegan ranch priced separately.

Vegan NY-style pizzas are priced by size: cheese $12.50/$19.75/$24.00, one topping $13.50/$21.75/$27.00, two toppings $14.50/$24.75/$30.00 and three toppings $15.50/$27.75/$33.00, with extra toppings at $1.00/$2.00/$3.00. Vegan meats count as two toppings. Specialty options include Vegan Pepperoni, Meatless, Veggie, Supreme, Dill Pickle, Buffalo Chicken Wing, Philly Style Steak, White Artichoke and Spinach, BBQ Chicken, Hawaiian and Tomato Pie.

Vegan Italian dinners include Spaghetti Marinara $12.00 and Chicken Parm, Pasta Primavera, Baked Rigatoni, Steak with Bell Peppers and Onion, and Eggplant Parm at $17.00. Vegan subs, in small and large sizes, cover Southern Fried Chicken, Chicken Parm, Eggplant Parm, Philly Style Steak, Buffalo Chicken and Veggie at $12.50/$17.50.

Gluten-free menu

Gluten-free appetizers include chicken fingers and fries $16.00, a side of fries $5.00, potato skins $12.00, cauliflower wings $14.00 and chicken wings at $8.00 for 5 pieces, $18.00 for 15 and $30.00 for 25. Gluten-free salads range from a $6.00 side to $16.00 for the Philly steak, Buffalo chicken and pizza salads.

Specialty gluten-free pies include Alexis' Pepperoni Lover $15.50, Meat Lover $17.00, Veggie $18.00, Supreme $19.00, Dill Pickle $15.00, Buffalo Chicken Wing $16.50, Philly Style Steak $17.00, White Artichoke and Spinach $15.50, Cinelli's Ricotta Pie $16.50, Hawaiian $16.50 and Waist Watcher $16.50.

Gluten-free dinners include Chicken Parm $17.50, Penne Marinara $13.50, Penne Primavera $17.50, Baked Ziti $16.50 and Sausage, Peppers and Onions $17.00, with grilled chicken available for $4. Featured gluten-free entrées add Steak, Peppers, Onions and Mushrooms $18.00, Chicken Alfredo $17.50, Garlic, Artichoke and Spinach $16.00 and Garlic, Oil and Broccoli $15.00. A side salad can be added to any entrée for $5.

Catering and group orders

Party pans and catering packages are offered for offices, teams and family gatherings, available seven days a week across Rochester and Greece, NY. Catering can be ordered online, and the restaurant is listed on ezCater for customers ordering through a company account.

Offers, loyalty and ordering

A daily "Spin the Slice" wheel offers one free spin per day, with prizes such as a free large cheese pizza, $5 off, a free cannoli and mozzarella sticks; prizes are used as coupons the following day. Signing up for the email and text list brings a $5 welcome code on orders of $25 or more, valid for one order with no expiration, and the phone number serves as the loyalty and Spin the Slice number. An optional Birthday Club sends a free-cannoli treat during the member's birthday month.

The Cinelli's app, added to a phone's home screen without an app store, saves favorites, tracks loyalty points and hosts Spin the Slice. App-only coupons include $5 off a first app order of $25 or more, $6 off delivery orders of $50 or more and a free 2-liter soda with any large specialty pizza, alongside rotating weekly offers. A "Dinner Decider" tool suggests dishes from the regular, vegan or gluten-free menus.

In brief

NY-style pizza and Italian-American classics

Photos

Select a photo to enlarge it.