Neapolitan pizzeria and bar · Columbus, Indiana, United States

Blacksheep Pizza

Neapolitan-style pizzas baked in a wood-fired oven, plus cast-iron steaks, appetizers, piadinas and a full bar of cocktails, wines and craft beers in Columbus, Indiana.

About Blacksheep Pizza

Wood-fired Neapolitan pizza in downtown Columbus

Blacksheep Pizza serves Neapolitan-style pizza from a wood-fired oven heated to 800 degrees. The kitchen is built around that oven: there is no fryer, no stove and no pot of boiling water, so the menu leans on fast, high-heat cooking. The pizzas use a 12-inch crust described as light and airy with a thick, puffy edge and charred spots from the intense heat.

The restaurant also operates a second location in Westfield, Indiana, and takes reservations through its website or by phone.

What is on the menu

Beyond the classic Neapolitan pizza, the kitchen prepares a cast-iron, oven-seared steak with truffle and ricotta potatoes. The menu is rounded out with a selection of appetizers, piadinas and entrees. A dedicated Pizzavant section lets diners customize a pizza with a special selection of toppings.

  • Neapolitan-style pizzas, 12-inch crust, baked in the wood-fired oven
  • Cast-iron, oven-seared steak with truffle and ricotta potatoes
  • Curated appetizers, piadinas and entrees
  • Customizable pizzas through the Pizzavant section
  • Kids' menu with kid-friendly options

Drinks

The full bar carries wines, craft beers and signature cocktails. The wine list is described as Italian and sommelier-selected. Cocktails range from seasonal favorites to classics.

Dietary needs and families

A gluten-free pizza crust is available, and many appetizers, salads and entrees can be modified to be gluten-free. The restaurant notes a higher risk of gluten contamination than for other food allergies and asks guests to inform their server. Staff also take other allergies seriously and ask diners to tell their server so they can dine safely. A kids' menu is offered.

Seating, service and payment

The dining room is designed for gatherings from intimate get-togethers to lively celebrations, though there are no private dining spaces. Outdoor dining is offered from March to October. At the time of writing, to-go orders were not available, with takeout planned to launch shortly after opening. Payment is accepted by major credit cards, debit cards and cash.

Parking in downtown Columbus

Public parking lots and street spots, including metered spaces, are available nearby. Most meters accept credit cards, and some local businesses provide designated customer parking; visitors should watch for time restrictions and special events.

In brief

Neapolitan pizza from a wood-fired oven

Photos

Select a photo to enlarge it.