
Bella Mia Cafe
Italian cafe in Bay Shore serving handcrafted paninis, Roman-style pinsas, gelato, espresso and evening cocktails, with catering and private events.
About Bella Mia Cafe
An Italian cafe in Bay Shore
Bella Mia Cafe is an Italian cafe on West Main Street in Bay Shore, New York, built around the idea of bringing the flavors and traditions of Italy to the neighborhood. Its offer spans the day: handcrafted paninis and Roman-style pinsas, authentic gelato and espresso, and evening cocktails.
Roman-style pinsa and the kitchen's approach
The pinsa is presented as a Roman-style specialty pizza made with a blend of soy, rice and wheat flour, all GMO-free. The cafe describes it as low in fat and calories and easy to digest. The kitchen states that it works with imported authentic ingredients and freshly prepared food, and that its menu consists of dishes of the kind found on a menu in Italy, covering both sweet and savory tastes.
Catering menus and party trays
Catering orders require a minimum of 24 hours' notice, prices are subject to change, and fresh bread is served with all catering orders. Trays come in two sizes: a half tray serving 8 to 10 and a full tray serving 18 to 20. Made-without-gluten catering options are available on request.
Salads and appetizers
- Caesar Salad: half tray $45, full tray $75
- Bella Mia House Salad: half tray $30, full tray $60
- Salad add-ons: grilled chicken half tray $20, full tray $40; grilled shrimp half tray $30, full tray $60
- Pinsa Platter with a choice of any three among Margherita, Prosciutto, Mortadella, Mediterranean and Calabrese: $50
- Homemade Meatballs, 12-piece minimum, $1.50 per meatball
- Mini Riceballs, 12-piece minimum, $2.50 per mini riceball
- Baked Clams, 12 per order, $35.00
Vegetables and pasta
- Eggplant Parmigiano: half tray $65, full tray $115
- Eggplant Rollatini: half tray $65, full tray $115
- Mixed Vegetables: half tray $45, full tray $80
- Roasted Potatoes: half tray $45, full tray $80
- Assorted Sandwiches: half tray $55, full tray $100
- Rigatoni alla Vodka: half tray $60, full tray $95
- Penne Marinara: half tray $50, full tray $80
- Baked Ziti: half tray $55, full tray $90
- Nonna's Orecchiette: half tray $65, full tray $95
Main courses
- Sausage & Peppers: half tray $70, full tray $120
- Chicken Scarpariello: half tray $70, full tray $120
- Francese, Marsala and Parmigiano, each available with chicken or veal: chicken half tray $70 and full tray $120; veal half tray $135 and full tray $225
- Chicken Cutlets: half tray $60, full tray $110
- Shrimp Vesuvio: half tray $85, full tray $135
- Salmon: half tray $95, full tray $150
Dessert
Pints of Bella Mia's homemade gelato are available at $12.50.
Private events
The cafe takes bookings for events and lists holiday parties, birthdays, showers, corporate events, graduations, reunions, milestone celebrations, anniversaries and private events among the occasions it hosts. Its event offer includes customizable prix fixe and buffet menus, dedicated event coordination, and elegant indoor and private dining spaces.
Visiting and ordering
Tables can be booked and orders placed online, and the cafe is reachable through its Instagram and Facebook profiles. It opens Tuesday to Saturday from 11am to 9pm and Sunday from 11am to 8pm, and remains closed on Mondays.
Roman-style pinsa, paninis and gelato
Photos
Select a photo to enlarge it.



