bakery and café · Worcester, Massachusetts, United States

Bean Counter Bakery

Family-owned Worcester bakery since 1998, known for decorated and wedding cakes, cupcakes, cookies, desserts and coffee, with gluten-free and vegan options.

About Bean Counter Bakery

A Worcester bakery and café since 1998

Bean Counter Bakery began in 1998 when founder and owner Alice Lombardi started selling desserts made in a licensed kitchen in her home to local Worcester businesses. Demand grew, and the first café opened on Highland Street in Worcester, Massachusetts, in 2001. A Shrewsbury café followed in 2008, giving the team more space to focus on wedding cakes, and in May 2020 the company opened a flagship store on Grove Street in Worcester. The Highland Street store was renovated in March 2024.

The bakery describes its desserts as handmade from scratch every day, using local and international ingredients sourced from Worcester to Madagascar to Belgium. Its range covers wedding cakes, celebration cakes and cupcakes, cookies, fine desserts and coffee, with gluten-free and vegan versions of cakes, cupcakes, cookies and other treats.

Decorated cakes and cupcakes

A rotating selection of decorated cakes is available to order without a custom request, with personalisation by filling, decor colours and writing. Published starting prices at the time of writing include:

  • Vintage Cake, Vintage Pastel Bow, Blush Petals Cake, Multicolor Blossom Cake, Daisy, Spring Flowers and Peony Garden from $67.00, with gluten-free and vegan options; several allow colour choices and two-tier versions.
  • Butterflies & Wildflowers, Funfetti Drip, Honey Bee Cake, Strawberry Fields Cake, Baseball Cake and Football Cake from $77.00.
  • Vintage Heart and Gender Reveal Vintage Heart from $107.00, with colour options.
  • Stars & Moon Cake from $107.00, with colour and decor options.
  • Pearls from $117.00, with colour options and two-tier availability.
  • Smash cakes from $15.00.
  • Rose Cupcakes from $8.50 and Pearls Cupcake from $8.00, both with colour options.

Wedding cakes

Popular wedding cake designs are offered for online pre-orders.

Pies, desserts and seasonal items

A Thanksgiving selection includes pies from $25.00 and gluten-free pies from $35.00, plus a Gobbler from $8.50. Other items listed are Pumpkin Brown Butter & Caramel at $78.00, Coconut Cream from $47.00, Carrot & Cream Cheese from $47.00, Pumpkin Cheesecake Cup at $7.50, Pumpkin Whoopie Pie at $5.00, Caramel Apple Bar at $5.00 and Pumpkin Muffin at $4.75. Several of these are marked gluten-free or vegan.

Custom orders and practical details

Wedding and custom order enquiries are handled through a contact form. The bakery asks for at least two to three weeks' notice for custom orders and aims to respond within 72 hours; customers who have not heard back are advised to check their spam folder and call. Cakes that do not require a custom order are listed under the cakes and decorated cakes section of the online menu.

The business operates two Worcester locations: the flagship store on Grove Street and the Highland Street shop. Online ordering is available for pick-up, and the bakery accepts American Express, Apple Pay, Diners Club, Discover, Google Pay, Mastercard and Visa.

Recognition

The bakery lists consecutive awards since 2010 and since 2011, membership since 2023, a Hall of Fame distinction and recognition from the Worcester Business Journal, along with induction into The Knot Hall of Fame in January 2015.

In brief

decorated and wedding cakes

Photos

Select a photo to enlarge it.