Ice cream shop · Warwick, New York, United States

Bellvale Farms Creamery

Hand-made ice cream and waffle cones, plus made-to-order ice cream cakes and pies, served at a family dairy farm in Warwick, New York.

About Bellvale Farms Creamery

A family dairy farm turned creamery

Bellvale Farms has produced dairy products in the Hudson Valley since 1819, across seven continuous generations of family farming. The creamery on the farm makes its ice cream and waffle cones by hand each day, using all-natural ingredients, and serves them at the top of Mount Peter in Warwick, New York, with views over Greenwood Lake.

What is scooped

The creamery's own flavors include Bellvale Bog, a dark chocolate ice cream with brownie dough and fudge swirl, and a banana ice cream with whiskey-caramel swirl. Scoops come in a traditional cone or a sundae bowl, and the homemade waffle cones are a signature of the shop. The flavor lineup changes, and the creamery publishes which flavors it is scooping for 2026.

Cakes, pies and take-home items

Ice cream cakes and pies are made to order, alongside ice cream sandwiches and pre-packed quarts. The published store list includes:

  • Great White Way Ice Cream Pie — white chocolate ice cream with raspberry swirl and dark chocolate chunks; serves 8–10.
  • Bellvale Bog Ice Cream Pie — dark chocolate ice cream with fudge and brownie dough; serves 8–10.
  • Ice Cream Sandwiches — Oreo cookie with vanilla or chocolate ice cream, six per package.
  • Pre-packed ice cream — quarts and 2.5-gallon tubs, with vanilla and a limited selection of other flavors depending on small-batch production.
  • Ice cream cakes — small (serves 4–8), large (serves 10–12) and party size (serves 20–25), built on chocolate cookie crunch with a layer of vanilla and chocolate ice cream.

How the cakes are finished

Cakes are finished with white buttercream and decorated with edible images for birthdays, Mother's and Father's Day, and graduations. The creamery does not write messages on cakes; customers who want a message can add cake gel bought from a third party or a local grocery store. Custom cakes can be made with any hard ice cream currently in production, in the same sizes, in a single flavor that includes whatever is in the chosen ice cream. Custom cake orders require a week's notice.

Visiting and ordering

The creamery sits at the top of Mount Peter in Warwick, a stop for hikers on the Appalachian Trail in need of a break. Orders for cakes, pies, sandwiches and pre-packed containers can be placed by phone. The shop has been recognized in local reader polls, including a Hudson Valley Magazine readers' vote and WPDH Radio listeners' choice for best ice cream in the Hudson Valley.

In brief

Hand-made ice cream and waffle cones

Photos

Select a photo to enlarge it.