Seafood market and kitchen · Wading River, New York, United States

Blue Water Fish

Fresh fish market and kitchen in Wading River, NY, selling dock-fresh seafood, prepared meals, soups and seafood salads for dine-in or takeout.

About Blue Water Fish

A fish market and kitchen in Wading River

Blue Water Fish is a seafood market and kitchen on Long Island's North Fork, opened Labor Day weekend 2021 by owner Tom Infantolino. The shop combines a retail counter of fresh fish with a kitchen that prepares take-out dishes to order, and it also offers seating for eating on site.

Fresh fish and shellfish

The market's stock centers on fish brought in from the docks, with local and regional species sold by the cut. Items listed in the current offer include Canadian salmon fillet, Peconic Bay oysters, littleneck clams, large shrimp, flounder, striped bass, sea scallops, Montauk tuna and swordfish. Availability follows the season and the day's catch, and some items can sell out.

Prepared meals and kitchen dishes

The kitchen cooks a menu of seafood favorites and prepared meals for lunch or dinner, either to eat there or to take away. The lineup includes:

  • Fish and chips, and a fried trio boat
  • Lobster bisque and New England clam chowder
  • Shrimp salad on a roll and lobster rolls
  • Stuffed sole, stuffed shrimp and shrimp scampi
  • Seafood salads, hot soups and appetizers
  • Fried flounder fillet sandwiches

Homemade fries and coleslaw accompany the menu, and a board lists daily seafood specials. A freezer section carries items such as Brazilian lobster tails, baked clams by the dozen and frozen chowders and bisques.

Background

Tom Infantolino is a second-generation restaurateur; his father founded the family fish business in 1972, and Tom began cooking at that Queens market while in high school. Before the Wading River shop, Blue Water operated in seafood trucking from 1994, delivering clams from Fire Island and Long Island's South Shore to the Fulton Fish Market in lower Manhattan. The Wading River market is the realization of his plan to open his own place in the town where he has lived for 25 years.

Buying and visiting

Orders can be placed by phone, and the shop also sells through its online store. The kitchen closes 30 minutes before the market each day. The market is closed Mondays.

In brief

Fresh local seafood and prepared seafood meals

Photos

Select a photo to enlarge it.