Key lime pie bakery · Tavernier, Florida, United States

Key Lime Pie Factory

Bakery in Tavernier, Florida Keys, known for its award-winning key lime pie, the famous Pie on a Stick, gourmet candies and a serenity garden.

About Key Lime Pie Factory

A Florida Keys pie destination on US1

Key Lime Pie Factory is a bakery and sweet shop in Tavernier, in the Florida Keys, located along US1. The adjacent lot provides parking that can accommodate RVs and boats, a practical detail for travellers driving the Overseas Highway.

The business presents itself as voted Best Key Lime in Florida and describes its pie as award-winning, with the tagline "Florida's Most Key Lime Pie." Visitors can order a slice, a whole pie, or the house specialty known as Pie on a Stick.

What visitors can buy

  • Key lime pie: sold by the slice or as a whole pie.
  • Pie on a Stick: the format the shop calls famous.
  • Gourmet candies: a separate line of sweets.
  • Key Lime Collection: a dedicated range of key lime products.
  • Gifts: unique gifts are offered alongside the food lines, and gift cards are also available.

Serenity Garden and Love Lock Way

The property includes a romantic serenity garden with Love Lock Way, presented as part of the visit rather than just a shop stop.

Practical conditions

The shop does not ship its pies or pies on a stick, so these items are only available at the Tavernier location. Customers can text the business for questions, and the site offers guidance on how to handle and store a pie.

In brief

Key lime pie and Pie on a Stick