New American bistro · South Hero, Vermont, United States

Blue Paddle Bistro

Owner-operated New American bistro in South Hero, Vermont, on Lake Champlain, run by Chef Phoebe Bright and Mandy Hotchkiss from 2005 until its closure in August 2026.

About Blue Paddle Bistro

A bistro in the Champlain Islands, now closed

Blue Paddle Bistro was an owner-operated restaurant in South Hero, Vermont, in the Lake Champlain Islands, about 20 minutes from Burlington. It was founded on March 14, 2005, by two friends, Chef Phoebe Bright and Mandy Hotchkiss, and announced its closure on August 9, 2026, after more than 21 years of operation. The proprietors attributed the decision to what they described as a perfect storm of circumstances.

The kitchen described its cooking as New American, with Chef Phoebe Bright preparing a little of everything. The house style was presented as consistent, delicious and unpretentious food. The restaurant was recognized in state and regional press over the years, including a Gayot listing of best restaurants with the best food in the Vermont area and multiple Daysie Awards as best restaurant or runner-up.

How the restaurant operated

Dinner was served Thursday through Sunday from 5:00 to 8:00 p.m., with Monday through Wednesday closed. Hours changed with the season, and Wednesday dinner service was added mid-June in summer. Sunday brunch ran every Sunday in the off-season, while in summer it was offered on special holidays. The restaurant also published a winter specialty cocktail list and a Sunday brunch menu.

Reservations were taken by phone rather than online, a deliberate choice by the owners to match each party with a suitable table. The phone line was answered seven days a week from 6:00 a.m. Take-out orders were also accepted by phone.

Food and drink

The menu centered on New American dishes, with mussels earning particular attention in outside coverage. The restaurant maintained a full bar; under Vermont state law, guests could not bring their own alcohol. Gluten-free pasta was not available. Gift cards were sold in hard copy and as eGift cards, and the bistro also offered branded Paddle apparel.

Dogs, music and personal touches

Dogs were welcome at outdoor tables during the warmer months, with water bowls and treats provided and leashes required. Wilbur, one of the resident Paddle Pups, was a regular presence. Live music was offered on Thursday evenings from 5:30 to 7:30 p.m. in winter, and every Thursday and Sunday in summer.

The owners cultivated small practical gestures: forwarding an edited photo of a guest's group the next morning, calling a party an hour ahead if their reservation appeared delayed, and delivering gift cards free within 20 miles when possible. The dress code was simply comfortable, with shoes and shirt required.

Recognition and community

Coverage cited by the restaurant included WCVB and NBC, Fox 44, Yankee Magazine, the Burlington Free Press, WPTZ, 7 Nights and Lufthansa Magazin. The Paddle Pups appeared for over a year on a Vermont Lottery scratch ticket called It's a Dogs Life. The bistro also hosted private parties and maintained a newsletter and an active Facebook page with guest photos, contests and music updates.

In brief

New American cuisine