
Benchwarmers Bagels
Wood-fired bagels, bagel sandwiches, pan-baked pizza and coffee in Raleigh, NC, with three locations, catering and wholesale options.
About Benchwarmers Bagels
Wood-fired bagels with a style of their own
Benchwarmers Bagels has been selling bagels in Raleigh since 2019. Its bagels are made with fresh-milled, pre-fermented heirloom grains, milled by Boulted Bread, and undergo a long, cold fermentation that gives them an open, airy texture. They are boiled in honey water and baked until dark in a wood-fired oven. The result is deliberately neither New York nor Montreal style: the shop describes its bagels as dark and airy, a style of its own.
The bagel sandwiches are described as Raleigh famous, and the coffee is brewed with local beans roasted by Jubala Coffee.
Three Raleigh locations
Benchwarmers operates three shops in Raleigh. The Transfer Co. Food Hall location at 500 E. Davie Street serves bagels and coffee Tuesday to Friday from 7 to 2 and Saturday and Sunday from 8 to 2, with pizza from 5 to 8 on Thursday, Friday and Saturday. The Rockway Building location next to Dix Park at 1015 S. Saunders Street opens Tuesday to Friday from 7 to 2 and Saturday and Sunday from 8 to 4. The North Hills location at 505 Hardimont Road opens Tuesday to Friday from 7 to 2 and Saturday and Sunday from 8 to 2.
Pizza in the evening
Pan-baked pizza is part of the offer, served at the Transfer Co. Food Hall location during evening hours on Thursday, Friday and Saturday. The pizza dough is made in-house, like the bagels, bagel chips, buns, cookies, brownies and other baked goods.
What is made in-house
Benchwarmers prepares much of its menu from scratch. In-house production includes lox, smoked fish, fried chicken, pork sausage, duck rillette, hickory-smoked bacon and mole-roasted pork shoulder; farm cheese, crema Oaxaca and queso fresco; cream cheeses, cashew spread, compound butters, marshmallow fluff, jams and jellies; all pickles and sauces, including pizza sauce and dressings; juices, chai mix and coffee syrups; overnight oats and granolas.
Catering and wholesale
The shop offers catering and wholesale options alongside its regular service, with a dedicated enquiry channel for both.
Local sourcing and partners
Benchwarmers sources locally where possible and works with farmers, millers, roasters, cheesemakers, artists and artisans across North Carolina. Its supplier list includes Anson Mills, Farm & Sparrow, Lindley Mills and Boulted Bread for grains; Appalachian Apiaries for honey; Boxcarr Handmade Cheese and Chapel Hill Creamery for cheeses; Carolina Packers for bologna and hot dogs; Crude Bitters for bitters; Escazu Chocolates and Videri for chocolate; Goodnight Brothers for country ham; Happy Dirt, Blue Sky Farms, Lee’s Produce, Moore’s Produce and Peedee Orchards for produce; Heritage Farms for sausage and bacon; Homeland Creamery for milk and cream; Joe Sink and Liz Kelly for pottery; Joyce Farms for meat and poultry; Latta’s Egg Ranch for eggs; Locals Seafood for seafood; My Spice Fix and Spicewalla for spices and tea; Nahunta Pork for pork products; Bay Six for merchandise; Paul Tuorto for design; and Spcl Signs for artwork.
Part of a Raleigh family of shops
Benchwarmers belongs to a family of Raleigh businesses that also includes Boulted Bread, Bright Spot Donuts and Jubala Coffee. It is owned by Head Baker Josh Bellamy, Andrew Cash, Sam Kirkpatrick and Head Chef John Knox, and led by General Manager Emily Sielatycki.
Wood-fired bagels and bagel sandwiches
Photos
Select a photo to enlarge it.



