BBQ restaurant · Pigeon Forge, Tennessee, United States

Bennett's Pit BBQ

Locally owned Pigeon Forge barbecue restaurant smoking pork, ribs, chicken and brisket over hickory for up to 14 hours, with a second location in Gatlinburg.

About Bennett's Pit BBQ

Hickory-smoked barbecue in Pigeon Forge

Bennett's Pit BBQ is a locally owned and operated barbecue restaurant on Parkway in Pigeon Forge, Tennessee, with a second location on River Road in Gatlinburg. The kitchen smokes pork ribs, chicken, pulled pork and beef brisket over smoldering hickory wood for up to 14 hours, basting the meat in the house sauce so the flavor reaches every layer. Because diners differ in how much sauce they want, the warm sauce is served on the side.

Starters and lighter plates

The lunch menu opens with shareable starters. Hickory wings come with blue cheese dressing and celery sticks in original hot or mild, or with a lemon pepper dry rub or a bourbon BBQ dry rub; they are priced at $12 for one pound and $22 for two. Deep fried pickle chips cost $12, and the Trailhead Combo brings together a choice of mild or hot wings, deep fried deviled eggs and pickle chips for $16. Potato skins are topped with Southwestern chili, homemade cheese sauce, scallions and bacon bits ($12), while pork rinds with BBQ seasoning and honey BBQ sauce cost $9, or two bags for $12. Pepper Jack cheese squares are hand breaded and fried and served with chili and sour cream ($12), and six hand-breaded deep fried deviled eggs come with homemade chow chow ($13). BBQ nachos pile chips with spicy cheese sauce, slow-smoked pork, onions, black olives and tomatoes, plus jalapenos, salsa and sour cream ($15).

Soups and salads include a tossed salad ($7), a dinner salad with a choice of chicken breast, fried chicken tenders, brisket or pulled pork ($15), a daily homemade soup ($6) and Cow Poke chili with ground beef, beans, tomatoes, cheese and scallions ($6). A no-meat option pairs a tossed salad with two sides for $14, and an all-you-can-eat salad bar with fresh vegetables, two soups and smoked chicken salad costs $16.

Lunch platters and sandwiches

Lunch platters come with a garlic biscuit and two sides chosen from coleslaw, deep fried corn, French fries, green beans, collard greens, potato salad, mac and cheese or BBQ beans; a baked potato or sweet potato can replace a side for $1. The selection includes pulled pork shoulder with Rowdy BBQ sauce ($15), sliced beef brisket smoked nightly and subject to availability ($19), a half smoked chicken ($16), burnt ends ($20), jumbo baby back ribs described as the house specialty ($15), fried fish with tartar sauce and lemon ($15), a grilled chicken breast with honey BBQ sauce ($16), chicken tenders ($16) and honey-BBQ jalapeno sausage ($16).

Sandwiches also include two sides, with the same $1 substitution for a baked or sweet potato. The Ultimate Sandwich offers pulled pork, sliced brisket, smoked jalapeno sausage or burnt ends on a hoagie roll with grilled onions and sweet honey BBQ sauce ($16). The pulled pork shoulder sandwich is billed as the one that made the restaurant famous ($14), and the Carolina pork sandwich adds coleslaw ($15). Other options are sliced brisket ($16), a fried chicken and pimento sandwich on a toasted brioche bun ($16), a spicy brisket Philly with peppers, mushrooms, jalapenos and Pepper Jack ($17), fried fish on a hoagie bun ($14, with American cheese for $1 more) and a chicken supreme with bacon and Monterey Jack ($15).

Burgers, ribs and combination platters

Chargrilled burgers use two patties and are served medium well. The bacon cheeseburger comes with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle ($15), and the brisket burger adds sliced smoked brisket and homemade brisket sauce ($18). Extras include bacon for $1.50 and grilled onions or sauteed mushrooms for $0.50 each.

Ribs and signature platters are served with a garlic biscuit and two sides. The BBQ Combo lets diners pick three smoked meats from pulled pork, quarter BBQ chicken, baby back ribs, honey-BBQ jalapeno sausage or beef brisket ($28), with white meat chicken for $2 more or burnt ends substituted for any meat for $3. Jumbo baby back ribs are smoked for up to six hours at 200 degrees and sold as a half rack ($22) or full rack ($32). The Texan Sampler combines all five smoked meats — pulled pork, brisket, jalapeno sausage, chicken and baby back ribs — for $32.

Visiting and ordering

The restaurant publishes separate lunch, dinner, dessert and side menus, a kids menu and a family feast available to go. Diners can join a waitlist for either the Pigeon Forge or Gatlinburg location, order online, and buy gift cards and shop products. Catering is also offered.

In brief

Hickory-smoked barbecue platters and ribs