Waterfront restaurant and bar · Ocean Bay Park, New York, United States

Flynn's Fire Island

Waterfront restaurant, day club and bar in Ocean Bay Park, Fire Island, known for seafood, cocktails, weddings and a dinner cruise. Closed until May 2027.

About Flynn's Fire Island

A Fire Island waterfront landmark

Flynn's Fire Island is a waterfront restaurant, day club and bar in Ocean Bay Park, on Fire Island, New York. It describes itself as a place reached by a short ferry or boat ride, with a marina where guests can pull up, and combines dining with a bar and daytime club atmosphere. The venue is currently closed and announces its reopening for May 2027.

Food and drink

The restaurant publishes separate lunch, dinner and drink menus, and its offer centres on seafood and cocktails served with waterfront views. Weekday happy hours are presented as family friendly. The site also lists a cocktail menu alongside the lunch and dinner menus.

Dinner cruise on the Moonchaser

One of the venue's distinctive experiences is a dinner cruise aboard the Moonchaser, which takes guests across the water to the restaurant. The outing is described as combining the summer breeze and sunset views with a party atmosphere and a buffet that includes steamed lobster, limited to one per person.

Weddings and private events

Flynn's markets itself as a venue for weddings and celebrations. The bay-front setting and rustic style are presented as suitable for weddings, bar and bat mitzvahs, corporate retreats, birthdays, anniversaries, family reunions and bachelorette parties. The facilities include an outdoor deck with sunset views, three bars, a large dancefloor and a spacious dining room able to accommodate large parties. A white sand beach a few steps away is suggested for wedding ceremonies, and chapels and synagogues are within a mile. The venue offers to help source bands, DJs, florists, photographers and a local baker for wedding cakes, and publishes wedding menus and catering options.

History

The business traces its origins to 1937, when John A. Flynn bought the restaurant from the Brooklyn Daily Eagle for $5,000. The property had been offered unsuccessfully as a retirement village for New York City police and firemen. At the time Ocean Bay Park had about 20 houses and no commercial businesses, and supplies arrived three times a week by a "vegetable boat". The building, which became known as "The Casino", was built as a clubhouse with a large dock for transient and seasonal slips.

The 1938 hurricane destroyed hundreds of homes on Fire Island but spared The Casino. John Flynn then closed it and rented The Oak Beach on the Jones Beach causeway, and later Maguire's Restaurant in Ocean Beach, where he built a profitable business until his lease expired in 1949. During that decade his five sons, Edward, John, Frank, James and William, helped him. With the lease gone, the family moved the operation back to Ocean Bay Park and gradually built up a large complex that in the 1980s included Flynn's Hotel, a short walk from the restaurant on the ocean. The hotel's main building had been the Point O' Woods Coast Guard station, dating to the 1880s and sold by the Coast Guard in 1949; Flynn bought it for $500 and acquired three other stations. The site describes Flynn's as a family-owned Long Island legacy of 80 years.

Getting there

The restaurant states that it is not accessible by car. Visitors are directed to the Fire Island ferries at the Seaview/Ocean Bay Park terminal in Bay Shore, New York, on the right side of the terminal, with driving directions given from the Long Island Expressway via the Sagtikos and Southern State parkways and local streets to Maple Avenue. A ferry schedule is published on the site.

Seasonal status: Flynn’s Fire Island reports that it is closed for the season until May 2027. Confirm its reopening schedule before planning a visit.

In brief

Waterfront seafood dining, bar and events

Photos

Select a photo to enlarge it.