Fill A Bagel & Breads
New York-style bagels mixed, boiled and baked on premises, plus fresh-made cream cheese spreads, muffins, pastries, specialty breads, a full-service deli and gourmet La.
About Fill A Bagel & Breads
Traditional New York style bagels in Jenkintown and Oreland
Fill A Bagel & Breads runs two Pennsylvania shops, in Jenkintown and Oreland, and describes itself as offering “the world on a bagel.” The core range is “traditional” New York style bagels, fresh made cream cheese spreads, muffins, pastries, specialty breads, a full service deli and gourmet La Colombe Coffees. The company frames the offer as having something for everyone and invites customers not to miss the experience.
Old Fashioned Goodness: how the bagels are made
Bagels are made the “Old Fashioned Way”: mixed, boiled and baked on the premises. The shop contrasts this with competitors whose bagels, it says, never see the inside of a factory. The daily bake covers 17 different types of bagels and up to 20 different types of breads and other goodies, and visitors can watch the bakers create their favorites on site. Breads are described as crusty on the outside and soft on the inside, with a taste only a hearth oven can create; a staff of three full time bakers prepares new and exciting items each dawn.
Deli sandwiches, salads and fillings
Only the freshest ingredients are used to assemble the hand crafted sandwiches. Deli sandwiches are stuffed with Dietz & Watson meats and cheeses, egg salad, chicken salad, tuna salad, whitefish and more, and the sliced Nova is said to be the best in town. Customers can fill a bagel or bread with just about anything they can imagine. The menu is presented as guaranteed to have something for every family member, including vegetarian and gluten free diets.
Vegetarian and gluten free options
- Vegetarian range: a large variety of cheeses, tossed garden salads, salad bagels, veggie hoagies, hummus and tofutti.
- Gluten free: any sandwich can be modified to use one of the partner’s gluten free bagel options.
- House favorites: avocado toast and arugula salad, described as “Fill A Bagel FAB.”
Bakery counter and drinks
Muffins, pastries, sticky buns and real NY style Black & White cookies are among the goodies baked daily, presented as a treat to give someone the sugar rush needed to get through an afternoon slump. The drinks list features excellent La Colombe coffees, espresso, cappuccino and gourmet teas.
History and team
Vicki and Charlie Ard opened Fill A Bagel in Jenkintown on June 14th, 1994 with 4 staff members, and word spread quickly that a little Jenkintown shop was making real NY style bagels. In the two years before opening, the couple ate bagels, talked about bagels and looked at bagel shops all over the United States, checking out over 50 shops in at least 6 states. Their goal was to make a great bagel and offer excellent customer service in a clean, reputable and community oriented shop, setting a standard by which others would model themselves. The business has grown considerably: it now employs a staff of nearly 50 people across 2 locations and operates under the name Fill A Bagel and Breads. It also contributes to the communities it serves and donates daily to local charities.
Ordering, catering and gift trays
Each shop page lists Order Online, a Take Out Menu and a Catering Menu, and the company says it strives to make catering a superior experience. Gift certificates are promoted as the perfect gift, and local delivery is available for gift baskets and holiday trays.
Joining the team
Fill A Bagel says it is always looking for motivated and hardworking people to join the team. Candidates download and complete an employment application and can either upload it or drop it off at either location; the form asks for name, email, number and the employment application itself.
Awards and recognition
- Philadelphia Magazine “Best Of Philly” — three time award winner.
- Eastern Montco Readers Choice Award, Best Bagels — awarded 1995 to present, best bagels every year.
- Eastern Montco Readers Choice Award, Best Coffee — 1996, 1997 and 1998.
- Philadelphia Inquirer “Best Of” — 2007 and 2008.
- The Happening List — 2013 to present.
- Talk of the Town — 2011 to present.
- 4.5 Star Winner.
- EMCC “Best of the Burbs” — 1994 to present.
- Bagel Independent, Best Bagels — 1997, 1998 and 2019.
- Business Woman of the Year, Eastern Montco Chamber of Commerce, 1999 — Vicki Ard, Fill A Bagel.
Holiday closures
Fill A Bagel closes to observe the following federal holidays: New Year’s Day, Easter, Memorial Day, Independence Day, Labor Day, Thanksgiving Day and Christmas Day.
New York style bagels and deli
Photos
Select a photo to enlarge it.



