Seafood restaurant · Hyannis, Massachusetts, United States

Black Cat Tavern

Waterfront seafood restaurant on Hyannis Harbor with a full bar, heated patio, piano lounge and two sister spots: Harbor Shack and Shack Out Back Raw Bar.

About Black Cat Tavern

A harbor-side seafood house in Hyannis

The Black Cat Tavern is a casual waterfront restaurant on the docks of Hyannis Harbor, in Cape Cod. Diners can eat inside in a classic seaside setting or outside on a heated patio overlooking the boats. The kitchen serves lunch, dinner and Sunday brunch, and the lounge hosts entertainment four nights a week. The tavern has a full bar and a piano lounge.

The menu spans thick burgers and garden-fresh salads alongside native seafood and prime beef. Delivery is also offered through the online ordering system.

Raw bar and chilled seafood

The tavern's raw bar section lists local Little Neck clams (six for 16.95), Barnstable oysters on the half shell (six for 19.95), Hot Shot oysters (six for 20.95) and a jumbo shrimp cocktail of four for 18.95. A raw bar trio at 23.95 combines two littleneck clams, two oysters and two shrimp cocktail. Ahi tuna sashimi is 19.95 and tuna poke 22.95, made with yellowfin tuna, avocado, seaweed salad, poke sauce, fresno chilis and crispy wontons. The chilled seafood tower, 89.95, serves two or more with seaweed salad, ahi tuna sashimi, chilled lobster tail, four shrimp cocktail, six oysters and six littleneck clams.

Soups, starters and fried plates

Soup of the day is 7.95 a cup or 9.95 a bowl. The clam chowder, described as award-winning, is 10.95 a cup or 13.95 a bowl, and lobster bisque is 16.95 a bowl. Native steamers, fried oysters and fried clams are priced at market. Steamed mussels (20.95) come with linguica, garlic herb butter, plum tomatoes, crushed red pepper and garlic crostini.

Tacos, quesadillas and salads

Tacos come in chicken (15.95), fried fish (18.95), seared tuna (19.95) and fried shrimp (19.95) versions. Quesadillas include a Mediterranean veggie option (15.95), chicken (16.95), buffalo chicken (17.95) and lobster (26.95). Salads range from a cucumber avocado salad (18.95) and a BLT wedge (15.95) to Mediterranean (17.95) and watermelon and feta (17.95); mixed green or classic Caesar is 15.95. Any salad can be topped with crab cake (27.95), grilled chicken (22.95), buffalo chicken (22.95), marinated steak tips (31.95), grilled salmon (27.95), a scallop and bacon skewer (25.95), tuna poke (28.95), lobster salad at market price or a lobster cake (29.95).

Sandwiches, burgers and fried seafood

Fried oyster and fried clam rolls are market priced. The giant Black Cat lobster roll is 42.95. The sandwich board, served with Cape Cod potato chips and a pickle, includes a buffalo chicken wrap (18.95), turkey BLT wrap (18.95), chicken Caesar wrap (18.95) and a lobster grilled cheese sandwich (35.95). Burgers come with skinny fries and a pickle: the Black Cat double stack (25.95) has two 6-oz Angus patties with lettuce, tomato, cheddar, bacon and fried onion rings on a brioche roll; the half-pound Angus is 18.95, 19.95 with cheese, 20.95 with cheese and bacon and 20.50 with bleu cheese. The Wianno burger (20.95) adds melted cheddar, horseradish sauce and crispy fried onions, the Hyport burger (21.95) has pepper jack, caramelized onions and steakhouse BBQ sauce on brioche, and a vegetarian burger is 18.95. Fried seafood plates, with skinny fries and cole slaw, include fish and chips (29.95), sea scallops (38.95), gulf shrimp (32.95), calamari (27.95) and a fried seafood platter of cod, whole belly clams, gulf shrimp and sea scallops with cole slaw, onion rings and skinny fries (46.95).

Baked dishes and harbor plates

Baked seafood comes with potato and vegetable: day boat scrod (30.95), baked sea scallops (37.95), baked seafood casserole (33.95) and baked stuffed shrimp (33.95). From the harbor, blackened day boat cod (37.95) is served with lobster and corn salsa, parmesan risotto and lemon butter; Asian chicken and shrimp stir fry (28.95) comes over rice; shrimp scampi (32.95) is finished with herbs over linguine; blackened swordfish (38.95) includes parmesan risotto, pineapple salsa and spicy mayo; grilled salmon (33.95) has cucumber and tomato salsa, roasted Yukon gold potatoes and poblano aioli; sesame-encrusted tuna steak (33.95) comes with kim chee, seaweed salad, jasmine rice and sweet chili sauce. Seafood scampi (46.95) combines shrimp, scallops and lobster over linguine, and scallop and lobster sauté (49.95) is served over rice in a Cajun Dijon cream sauce. A tuna poke bowl is 34.95. Lobster preparations include lobster trap boiled and baked stuffed one-pound lobster, single or double, with potato and vegetable, and lazy man lobster Newburg, all at market price.

The Harbor Shack next door

The Black Cat Harbor Shack sits next to the tavern on Hyannis Harbor. Guests can eat Cape Cod fare on the front porch while watching the ferries, or have orders packed to go. The Shack has a full bar and opens Friday from 4pm to close and Saturday and Sunday from 11:30am to close.

Its appetizers include stuffed quahog (10.95), fried onion rings (12.95), fried mozzarella sticks (12.95), chicken tenders (16.95), buffalo tenders (16.95), garlic parmesan wings (16.95), buffalo wings (16.95), scallops wrapped in bacon with avocado crema (21.95), buffalo cauliflower (16.95), baked stuffed mushroom caps (14.95), crab cake (17.95) and lobster cake (20.95). Steamers are market priced at 1¼ pounds of native soft shell clams with broth and drawn butter; steamed mussels are 19.95 with plum tomatoes, scallions and a garlic white wine sauce. Clams casino are 17.95, shrimp cocktail 17.95, Hot Shot oysters 19.95, the raw seafood trio 21.95, select oysters 18.95, tuna sashimi 18.95, Little Neck clams 15.95 and lobster tail cocktail market priced. Tuna poke is 22.95. Soups and salads include clam chowder (9.95 cup, 12.95 bowl), lobster bisque (12.95 cup, 15.95 bowl), mixed green salad (12.95), Caesar (14.95), BLT wedge (14.95), Mediterranean (15.95) and watermelon and feta (16.95), with add-ons such as grilled chicken (7.00), grilled shrimp (11.00), grilled salmon (14.00), fresh lobster salad at market, grilled sirloin tips (15.00), scallops and bacon (11.00) and tuna poke (15.00).

Shack Out Back Raw Bar

Tucked behind the Harbor Shack, the Shack Out Back Raw Bar is an outdoor spot with a roomy bar where oysters and clams are shucked to order, plus covered tables. It serves classic Cape Cod fare such as fried seafood, lobster rolls and the award-winning chowder, with a full bar and live entertainment all season. It opens Friday from 4pm to close and Saturday and Sunday from 11:30am to close.

Its raw selection lists Little Neck clams (six for 16.95), select oysters (six for 19.95), Hot Shot oysters (six for 20.95), jumbo shrimp cocktail (four for 18.95), a seafood sampler of two littleneck clams, two select oysters and two shrimp cocktail (23.95), lobster tail cocktail at market price, ahi tuna sashimi (18.95) and tuna poke (22.95). Appetizers include New England clam chowder (10.95 cup, 13.95 bowl), lobster bisque (13.95 cup, 16.95 bowl), steamers at market price, 1¼ pounds of steamed mussels (20.95), crab cake (17.95), lobster cake (21.95), buffalo cauliflower (17.95), fried onion rings (13.95), fried mozzarella sticks (13.95), skinny fries (7.95), sweet potato fries (9.95), chicken tenders (17.95), buffalo tenders (17.95), garlic parmesan wings (17.95), buffalo wings (17.95), baked stuffed mushroom caps (15.95), baked stuffed quahog (11.95), scallops wrapped in bacon (24.95) and baked clams casino (18.95). Tacos, two soft shell each, come in grilled chicken (15.95), fried fish (18.95), ahi tuna (18.95) and fried shrimp (19.95) versions. Salads include mixed green (13.95), Caesar (15.95), BLT wedge (15.95), Mediterranean (16.95) and watermelon and feta (17.95), with add-ons such as grilled chicken skewer (8.00) and grilled shrimp.

In brief

Cape Cod seafood and raw bar