Seafood restaurant · Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, United States

Benny's Coastal Kitchen

Waterfront seafood restaurant on Hilton Head Island, SC, opened in 2024, with indoor and outdoor dining, a rooftop bar and seasonal menus.

About Benny's Coastal Kitchen

A waterfront seafood house on Skull Creek

Benny's Coastal Kitchen occupies a 9,600-square-foot building completed in early 2024 on Shrimpers Row, off Squire Pope Road, on Hilton Head Island, South Carolina. The restaurant sits on the waterfront with views of Skull Creek, and its name honors Benny Hudson, described as a patriarch of seafood harvesting. The property includes several indoor dining rooms, outdoor seating and a rooftop bar, with the shrimp boat dock and fish house in view at sunset. It is part of the Coastal Restaurants and Bars group.

Menus built around the season

The kitchen describes its offer as seasonal cooking paired with handcrafted cocktails. The published dinner menu is organized into starters, salads, main plates and a raw bar selection.

Starters and raw bar

  • Oyster bisque with crispy oyster and black urfa
  • Oysters on the half-shell, offered as May River oysters or a daily selection, by the six or the dozen
  • Seared scallop with delicata squash purée, crispy shallot and apple cabbage slaw
  • Skillet shrimp with black garlic butter, parsley, sherry and bread
  • Carpaccio with chili aioli, caraway crisps, radicchio and pickled Fresno chiles
  • Brisket arancini with cheddar, onions, poblano and charred onion aioli
  • Fried Brussels sprouts with onions, peppedew, Parmesan and smoked chili glaze
  • Warm brie dip with jalapeño bacon jam, crispy shallots and bread
  • Hushpuppies with Turkish chili-honey butter
  • A chilled seafood tower with scampi, clams, poached shrimp, shucked oysters and Alaskan snow crab legs

Salads

  • Fall harvest salad with apple, bleu cheese, arugula, grapes, walnut, delicata squash and walnut miso vinaigrette
  • Hearty greens salad with napa cabbage, baby kale, carrots, tomatoes, chèvre, roasted poblano goddess dressing and crostini
  • Beet salad with bibb lettuce, balsamic blueberries, pistachios, chili-mascarpone, benne seed lace cookie and champagne vinaigrette
  • Caesar salad with gem lettuce, pumpernickel croutons, pepitas, Gouda, Parmesan, radicchio and crispy shallots

Main plates

  • Benny's Bounty: fried whole catch with Savannah red rice, collard greens and charred onion aioli
  • Salmon papillote with apple, fennel, delicata squash, potatoes and cranberry-fennel beurre blanc
  • Grilled swordfish with cheddar grits, collards and tomato-fennel butter
  • Blackened drum with cheddar grits, corn and Sea Island pea succotash and seafood poblano velouté
  • Pepita-herb crusted grouper with pumpkin, collard greens and fall beurre blanc
  • Crab cakes with corn and Sea Island pea succotash, carrots and seafood poblano velouté
  • Seared scallops with mushroom risotto, fig arugula salad and hazelnuts
  • Brazilian fish stew with coconut milk, shrimp, clams, fish, scallops, peppers, onions and Carolina Gold rice
  • Seafood fritto misto with fried shrimp, scallops, oysters and fresh fish, pickled vegetables, harissa aioli and natural fries
  • Diavolo blanco: spicy seafood pasta with scallop, shrimp, lobster, bucatini, vegetables and spicy sauce
  • Fall dumplings with pumpkin velouté, delicata squash, bell peppers, onions, oyster mushrooms, spiced walnuts and fried sage
  • Seafood pot pie with shrimp, fish, lobster, potatoes, onions, peppers and sherry cream
  • Beef filet with black garlic-brown butter, truffled potatoes, asparagus and tamarind jus
  • Short rib ragu with fried masa gnocchi, crispy shallots, burrata, peppers and onions
  • Petite pork shanks with confit potato, warm apple-cabbage slaw and mushroom demi-glace
  • Chili-glazed chicken, panko-fried, with broccolini

Service and reservations

The restaurant serves lunch, dinner, Sunday brunch and a drinks menu. Tables can be reserved online through Resy or by calling the restaurant directly. Private event inquiries are handled through an event request form, and the restaurant also offers gift cards and an email newsletter.

Events and weekly entertainment

Benny's hosts weekly entertainment and a rotating calendar of events. The venue's event spaces are presented as suitable for coastal weddings and other private celebrations.

In brief

Seafood and raw bar

Photos

Select a photo to enlarge it.