Black-Eyed Susans
Beach casual restaurant and tavern in Harvey Cedars, NJ, open year-round, serving artisan pizzas, house-made pastas, seafood and cocktails.
About Black-Eyed Susans
A beach casual restaurant and tavern in Harvey Cedars
Black-Eyed Susans is a beach casual restaurant and tavern in Harvey Cedars, New Jersey, opened in 2009 by chef partners Ashley Pellagrino and Christopher Sanchez. It operates year-round and describes itself as a place to gather, savor and celebrate everyday moments. The kitchen builds a rotating menu of artisan pizzas, house-made pastas, fresh seafood, salads and shareable plates, with dishes that aim to be both creative and approachable.
Sourcing and drinks
Menus follow seasonally available ingredients, much of it sourced from local farms, distributors and fishermen. The restaurant states it uses many organic ingredients, sustainably caught fish and seafood, and pasture-raised meats, and that it has spent 15 years building relationships with farmers and fishermen. Wines are chosen for value, with a certified level II sommelier on staff selecting bottles to accompany the cuisine. Cocktails use fresh ingredients and selected spirits, designed to be enjoyed on their own or with food.
Dinner menu
The dinner menu is organized into starters, salads, mains, pizzas and sides. Starters include warm marinated olives with citrus and herbs, whipped ricotta with olive oil, honey, pine nuts and sourdough, fried artichokes with parmesan, lemon and pesto aioli, mussels with pork lardons, white wine, fennel, crème fraîche and Calabrian chili, shrimp toast with roasted tomato and garlic aioli, tempura cauliflower with sweet-and-sour sauce, polpette arrabbiata (Sicilian-style meatballs with pistachios, sultanas and ricotta), seared tuna with black garlic-miso aioli, avocado, kimchi and ponzu, and a half loaf of LBI sourdough with house-made butter and herbs.
Salads are a black garlic Caesar with baby romaine, parmesan and breadcrumbs, and an arugula salad with Bulgarian feta, delicata squash, apple, sunflower seeds, pepitas and preserved lemon vinaigrette. Mains range from lobster gnocchi with broccoli rabe, Calabrian chili and parmesan fondutta, and bucatini cacio e pepe, to lumache pasta with mushroom, garbanzo, shallot, garlic, greens and ricotta. Seafood and meat mains include grilled swordfish with spinach-miso purée, kabocha squash, French green beans, sesame and crispy garlic; Viking Village tuna with farro risotto, leeks, wild mushrooms and red wine demi; a 14 oz Niman Ranch NY strip steak with glazed broccolini and red wine demi; Viking Village scallops with sunshine kabocha squash, red onion and mojo picón; wild-caught salmon with Brussels sprouts, pork lardons, quinoa and parsnip purée; and pan-seared tilefish with coconut-green curry, squash, snap peas and shiitake. An agnolotti changes regularly, and a double cheeseburger comes with American cheese, lettuce, pickle, onion, secret sauce and herb fries.
Pizzas include a traditional tomato, mozzarella, oregano and Seven Sisters pie; margherita with fresh mozzarella and basil; pepperoni with Biellese pepperoni, oregano, mozzarella and St. Malachi; burrata with pecorino, broccoli rabe, Calabrian chili and garlic; bianco verde with mozzarella, ricotta, arugula, pine nuts and lemon; sausage with tomato, mozzarella, fennel and onion; clam pie with pecorino, parmesan, lemon, oregano and pangrattato; hot honey chicken with mozzarella, pickled red onion and red pepper flakes; polpette pie with meatballs, pistachios, arrabbiata sauce and mozzarella; and an angry crab pie with arrabbiata, mozzarella, jumbo lump crab and Calabrian chili, priced at market. Sides are broccoli rabe with garlic and Calabrian chili, creamy polenta with extra virgin olive oil and parmesan, French fries with herbs, roasted garlic aioli and ketchup, and farro risotto with wild mushrooms and leeks.
Cocktails and happy hour
The drinks list groups spritzes, house originals, reimagined classics, mini-martinis and wine. Spritzes include a Paloma with Tequileño blanco, Aperol, lime, grapefruit soda and prosecco; a Sicilian Sbagliato with lemoncello, Luxardo Bitter, blanc vermouth, lemon bitters, prosecco and soda; an Aperol spritz; a Hugo spritz with elderflower, mint, prosecco and soda; and a Sarti spritz described as Aperol's fruitier cousin with notes of blood orange, passionfruit and mango. Several spritzes can be made zero-proof.
House originals include Suzy's Margarita with Tequileño blanco, citrus, agave, Italian orange liqueur and citrus salt; Flora & Fauna with cucumber vodka, elderflower, rosemary and lemon; a Painkiller with coconut rum, pineapple, orange, coconut and nutmeg; and Lychee-Licious with gin, lychee, lime and butterfly pea flower. Reimagined classics include a brown butter corn old fashioned, a strawberry coconut negroni, Figgin' Good with G4 blanco tequila, fig, amaro, allspice dram and lime, an aloe daiquiri, a toasted Manhattan and a rhubarb-basil cosmo. Mini-martinis come in dirty, classic and espresso versions, and a sangria sour is also listed. Wines change frequently and a current list is available on request.
Happy hour runs daily from 4 to 5 PM at the bar and garden bar, with $2 off all drafts, $10 house wines and $12 Suzy's Margarita, Flora & Fauna, Aperol Spritz and Hugo Spritz. Happy-hour food includes a 10-inch Bavarian pretzel with pimento cheese and mustard, crispy artichokes, a double cheeseburger, a fried chicken sandwich with Calabrian chili honey, garlic aioli and pickles, pizza puffs with parmesan, black pepper, lemon and marinara, French fries, and an 18-dollar pizza in traditional, pepperoni or pizza-of-the-day versions.
Seating, reservations and policies
Starting October 7, the main dining area operates exclusively on a walk-in basis. A limited number of reservations remain available for the second-floor dining room, for guests over the age of 12. The restaurant does not offer a dedicated children's menu but can modify select à la carte items for younger palates; children are asked to remain seated at the table, fussy infants and toddlers to be comforted outside the dining room, and strollers are not permitted in the dining space, though a limited number of highchairs are available on request. Credit card transactions carry a 2.99% service fee.
Private events
Groups larger than eight guests can gather in the second-floor dining room, which also serves as a private event space when not in standard use. It has a private bar, dining areas and lounge seating, seats up to 45 guests and accommodates receptions for up to 60. Groups exceeding 60 require a full buy-out of the first and second floor dining areas. The first-floor dining room is available for private events that conclude before 3 PM or take place on days the restaurant is closed. Events are not offered in the outdoor dining areas.
Artisan pizzas, house-made pastas and fresh seafood
Photos
Select a photo to enlarge it.



