Barbecue restaurant · Gordonsville, Virginia, United States

The BBQ Exchange

Barbecue restaurant in downtown Gordonsville, VA, serving hickory-smoked pork, ribs, brisket and chicken with homemade sides, sauces and desserts.

About The BBQ Exchange

Virginia-style barbecue in downtown Gordonsville

The BBQ Exchange is a quick-counter and take-out barbecue restaurant in downtown Gordonsville, Virginia. Its kitchen works with hickory smoke and slow roasting, and the house style is presented as real Virginia barbecue. Pork shoulders and spareribs are dry cured with secret-ingredient rubs and then cooked in a specialized wood-burning cooker. Chicken halves are grilled over live coals, in the roadside tradition associated with Saturday barbecue sales across the Eastern seaboard.

The dining room is built for a relaxed family meal: a rustic building with whitewashed tin siding and a forest green roof, barn-board walls and ceiling fans that give the main room a pavilion-like feel. Cedar picnic tables are covered with paper rolls, and each table holds a caddie of homemade sauces.

Sandwiches and combos

All sandwiches come in one size and are served with coleslaw, pickles and barbecue sauce on the side. The main list includes pulled pork, pulled chicken, sliced or chopped beef brisket, Fu-Q (smoked tofu), pork belly, a sausage link, a BLT on a soft roll, a BLT with pork belly and Salmon Q. Any sandwich can be made a combo with fries or hushpuppies for $2 more.

Specialty sandwiches, also available as combos for an extra $2, are built with multiple components:

  • Belly-Q — collard greens, onions, peppers, crispy pork belly and Colonel Bacon sauce.
  • Purgatory — pimento cheese, pork brisket, fried green tomato, mustard pickles and Colonel Bacon sauce.
  • Heaven — sticky love bacon, lettuce, tomato, fried egg, pulled pork, fried potato and baconnaise.
  • Hell — tempura-battered bacon, habanero mac & cheese balls, sambal, pepper spread, pulled pork and five hot sauces; available in-house only.

Platters, salads and soups

Platters come with two small sides and a choice of cornbread, pumpkin muffin or roll. Fries or hushpuppies can be substituted for $2, and onion rings or fried pickles for $3. The platter options are pulled pork (6 oz), pulled chicken (6 oz), sliced brisket (6 oz), Fu-Q (6 oz), chicken wings in six or twelve pieces, half a grilled barbecue chicken, pork belly, two smoked sausage links, ribs in four-, eight- or twelve-bone portions, and smoked salmon.

The BBQ Lovers Platter lets diners combine pulled pork, pulled chicken, brisket, ribs, sausage or pork belly: two meats total 8 oz, three meats 12 oz and four meats 16 oz. Wings can be ordered with a choice of sauce or dry rub — Craig's Carolina, Hog Fire, QX Sweet, Virginia Sweet or Colonel Bacon — as a six-piece, six-wing combo, twelve-piece or twelve-wing combo.

Salads and soups round out the menu. An entrée salad comes with a choice of homemade dressing (ranch, barbecue, balsamic, Caesar or blue cheese), and pork, brisket, chicken or salmon can be added for $7 to $12. A small tossed salad is also listed. Brunswick stew or the soup of the day is served with a choice of roll, cornbread or pumpkin muffin.

Sides, breads and desserts

Sides are sold in small 5-oz portions or 16-oz pints. The lineup includes baked beans, macaroni and cheese, collard greens, broccoli salad, pepper cabbage, spicy coleslaw, home-style coleslaw, green beans, potato salad, macaroni salad and house-made pickles. The pickle selection extends to pickled sweet peppers, garlic pickles, sweet pickles, horseradish pickles, pickled green tomatoes, hot peppers, spicy pickles, mustard pickles, dill pickles and pickled onions.

Breads are available by the piece, half-dozen or dozen: cornbread, pumpkin muffins and rolls. Desserts include homemade cupcakes, cookies and brownies. Fried items are offered in one size: French fries, hushpuppies, onion rings, fried pickles and fried green tomatoes.

Meats by the pound and family meals

For take-home meals, meats are sold by the half-pound or pound: pulled pork, pulled chicken, sliced or chopped beef brisket, pork belly, sausage links (two or four), smoked tofu, half chicken (one or two), and smoked ribs (four, eight or twelve).

Family dinners are designed to feed four people and include four pumpkin muffins, three 16-oz sides, two 4-oz sauces and a choice of four rolls or cornbread. They are priced to-go only; enjoying a family dinner in the restaurant adds a $5 upcharge. The family meal options are pulled pork (1 lb), pulled chicken (1 lb), beef brisket (1 lb), grilled chicken (two half pieces) and ribs (two eight-bone racks).

Sauces and hot sauces

The house sauces are sold in 2-oz, 4-oz and bottle sizes. Hog Fire is described as a fiery sauce layered with spices and hot peppers; Colonel Bacon is the original Virginia-style sauce anchored by smoky bacon and a blend of mustards; Craig's Carolina draws on the barbecue houses of the Carolinas; QX Sweet is a Kansas City-style sauce balancing sweet and spice; and Virginia Sweet uses roasted onions, apple butter and a secret red rub.

A separate line of specialty hot sauces is available, with availability confirmed by phone: Pickled Ghost Peppers, Poltergeist Smoked Ghost Peppers, Hell Fire Juiced Ghost Peppers and Napalm Juiced Habanero pepper, all in 2-oz bottles.

Ordering and visiting

Call-in orders are welcome, and online ordering is available. Gift cards can be purchased through the website. The restaurant also handles catering and publishes a holiday menu. Prices and availability are subject to change without notice.

In brief

Virginia-style hickory-smoked barbecue

Photos

Select a photo to enlarge it.