Bakery · Evansville, Indiana, United States

Be Happy Pie Company

Full-service bakery in Evansville, Indiana, making sweet and savory pies from scratch since 2015, with pickup, catering and nationwide shipping.

About Be Happy Pie Company

A bakery built around pies

Be Happy Pie Company is a full-service bakery established in 2015 that specializes in pies and other baked goods, all made from scratch. Its range covers both sweet and savory lines: fruit and crumb-topped pies, scones, cookies, coffee cake, sweet rolls, cheesecakes, cookie pies and cream puffs, alongside savory options such as chicken pot pie, fiesta taco pie, shepherd's pie and quiche.

The bakery operates a storefront on the west side of Evansville, Indiana, where pies are baked daily and customers can place pickup orders. It also runs a second Evansville location on the east side and a Kansas City-area shop in Gladstone, Missouri.

Sweet and savory offerings

The sweet side of the menu centers on pies, including crumb-topped varieties, alongside cheesecakes, cookie pies, cream puffs, scones, cookies, coffee cake and sweet rolls. The savory side covers full meals in pie form, with chicken pot pie, fiesta taco pie, shepherd's pie and quiche among the documented options.

Ordering, shipping and seasonal demand

Customers can order for pickup at the shops or have pies shipped nationwide. Shipped orders travel by UPS, with ground, next-day air and second-day air service; residents of Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Hawaii, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, North Dakota, Oregon, South Dakota, Utah, Washington and Wyoming are offered only air shipping so the pies arrive quickly. Orders are dispatched only on Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Thursdays, and orders placed after 10 a.m. are processed on the next shipping day.

Thanksgiving is a major period for the bakery, which takes holiday pie pre-orders with a published deadline. The company also lists catering, fundraising and a mobile app for ordering and tracking rewards among its services.

Practical conditions

The bakery states that it does not offer refunds; if a customer is dissatisfied, it may replace a pie depending on the circumstances, and for shipped items the cost of materials and shipment in a replacement falls to the customer. The kitchen is not allergy-free and cross-contamination is possible, so customers with gluten, dairy, nut, peanut or other food allergies are advised to err on the side of caution.

In brief

Sweet and savory pies made from scratch

Photos

Select a photo to enlarge it.