Flanders Fish Market
Family-owned Connecticut seafood market, restaurant and caterer since 1983, selling fresh fish, lobster, chowders and prepared meals.
About Flanders Fish Market
A Connecticut seafood institution since 1983
Flanders Fish Market began in the fall of 1983, when Paul and Donna Formica drove past a small one-bedroom home on Chesterfield Road in Flanders, Connecticut, and saw a fish market in it. More than four decades later, the business describes itself as Connecticut's largest full-service fresh fish market, seafood restaurant, bar and catering operation, and has been named to the Connecticut Restaurant Association Hospitality Hall of Fame. Donna Formica died in 2009; three of her daughters now sit on the leadership team, and the business is in its second generation of family ownership.
Freshness is tied to a direct supply line: trucks make multiple weekly trips to the Boston Fish Pier to collect fish and seafood for the market and kitchen.
What the market sells
The retail side covers live and prepared lobster, shrimp and fish, soups, spices and sauces, housewares and branded merchandise. Live Maine lobsters and prepared lobster items are sold alongside the raw catch. The online shop is organised into sections for live lobster, prepared lobster, shrimp and fish, soups, spices and sauces, housewares, event tickets, holiday meals for in-store pickup, and Flanders Fish Market merchandise.
Among the most popular products listed are:
- Lobster Pot Pie, $24.00
- Live Lobster, $25.00
- Lobster Bisque, $34.00
- Creamy Clam Chowder, $22.00
- Cappy's Shrimp Cocktail, $26.99
- Clear Clam Chowder, $22.00
Featured items also include Tears of Joy Cocktail Sauce at $8.99 and a Soup Trio at $72.00. The bisque is labelled as made with hard-shell Maine lobster meat, the creamy chowder with hand-shucked Boston clams, and the clear chowder as gluten free. Holiday meals are sold for pickup: a Thanksgiving Dinner To-Go is listed at $300.00 and a Christmas Dinner To-Go at $350.00, the latter marked out of stock at the time of writing.
Restaurant, bar and catering
The kitchen serves seafood and pub-style food; the menu is described as covering crab, warm lobster bisque, burgers and other dishes. Guests can eat in either of two dining rooms, at the bar, on the outdoor patio by the fire pits, or in a private dining experience at the Chef's Table. Takeout orders can be placed by phone or through the website.
Catering is available both on site, in the remodeled dining spaces, and off site using custom clambake wagons. The business also offers local and national delivery of market products.
Recognition and coverage
Flanders Fish Market was voted "Best Seafood" by Connecticut Magazine and "Best Lobster Roll" in southeastern Connecticut and southern Rhode Island by readers of The Day. It has been featured on the Food Network and in Coastal Living Magazine, The New York Times and Rachael Ray. The site also displays a 2026 TripAdvisor Travelers' Choice award.
Who runs it
The leadership team includes Ali Formica Coleman as Director of Brand and Business Development, Hannah Formica as Director of Operations, Olivia Formica as Culinary Director, Jennaya Morey as General Manager and Pat Sullivan as Chef.
Service area
The business serves East Lyme, Old Lyme, Old Saybrook, Waterford, New Haven, Essex, New London, East Haddam, Groton and Niantic, Connecticut, and surrounding communities.
Other restaurants in the group
The Flanders Fish Restaurant Group also operates 374 Kitchen + Cocktails in Niantic, described as elevated comfort food and craft cocktails and established in 2024, and the seasonal Crescent Beach Stand, a seaside quick-service breakfast and lunch spot in Niantic that Flanders Fish Market took over in 2019.
Fresh seafood market, lobster and chowders
Photos
Select a photo to enlarge it.



