Neighborhood bakery · Boerum Hill, Brooklyn, New York, United States

Betty Bakery

A Boerum Hill, Brooklyn bakeshop with a retro-modern take on American classics: cakes, cupcakes, cookies, pies and custom orders.

About Betty Bakery

A Boerum Hill bakeshop with a retro-modern bent

Betty Bakery is a neighborhood bakeshop in the heart of Boerum Hill, Brooklyn. Its baking follows a mid-century, retro-modern idea: American classics of the kind that came out of a grandmother's kitchen, updated with a contemporary twist. The shop sells both in person at its Atlantic Avenue storefront and through its online store, which was rebuilt to make ordering from home convenient.

Cakes and cupcakes

Cakes are the largest part of the range and are organized into several collections. Classic Cakes, Signature Cakes, Decorated Cakes and Specialty Cakes cover pre-designed options, while separate Gluten Free Cakes and Vegan Cakes lines serve customers with dietary restrictions. Cupcakes are sold as their own category.

A Build Your Own Cake tool lets customers mix and match cake layers, fillings and frosting flavors to create combinations not found on the Classic, Signature or Specialty menus. Cakes ordered this way are finished in the bakery's standard simple style and do not include custom decorative design, custom piping or themed decorations beyond the options shown in the tool. Customers looking for a specific aesthetic or a pre-designed favorite are directed to the curated Classic, Signature and Specialty collections.

Cookies, bars and pies

The bakery also sells Cookies & Bars, described as a selection of fresh-baked classic cookies. Under Sweet & Savory Pies it lists Savory Pies, Sweet Pies and Small Fruit Pies; the savory pies are described as personal-sized and versatile for any occasion. A Ring Dings & Retro Goodies line and a Gender Reveal category round out the offering.

Seasonal whole pies are sold in 10-inch sizes, with examples including an Award Winning Brown Butter Pumpkin Pie, Double Crust Apple Pie, Pecan Pie, Hudson Valley Dutch Apple Pie, Chocolate Chunk Pecan Pie, NY Sour Cherry Pie, Violet Sweet Potato Pie, Blueberry Pie and a lactose-free Pumpkin Pie. Other items include an Old Fashioned Apple Cake and decorated holiday cookies for Thanksgiving. Whole cakes are available for pickup only.

Ordering, delivery and lead times

Orders placed directly with the bakery require a 48-hour lead time. Delivery is calculated at checkout when available. For same-day needs, the shop points customers to Sauce, Grubhub and DoorDash, which can deliver most in-house items; whole cakes remain pickup-only through those channels. Customers who want whole cakes, cookies or other items delivered can arrange delivery directly with the bakery.

Custom and decorated cakes

Beyond the standardized online range, the bakery takes custom order requests through a quote form and responds within one to two business days to confirm the final details. Custom-decorated cakes for special events are handled by the cake design team by email with event details and design ideas. Simple custom decorations require at least 72 hours' advance notice, while complex or intricate designs need additional lead time, so the bakery asks customers to order as far in advance as possible.

In brief

Cakes, cupcakes and pies

Photos

Select a photo to enlarge it.