Bethel Bakery
Family-owned bakery in Bethel Park, PA, operating since 1955 and known for cakes, cookies, wedding cakes and holiday desserts.
About Bethel Bakery
A Pittsburgh-area bakery since 1955
Bethel Bakery is a family-owned bakery that has operated since 1955, with its main shop on Brightwood Road in Bethel Park, Pennsylvania. The bakery prepares cakes, cookies, breakfast items and seasonal desserts, and runs a dedicated wedding department for couples planning a wedding cake.
Cakes and custom designs
Cakes are a central part of the offer. The decorating team hand-designs seasonal cakes, including Thanksgiving designs such as a Pilgrim Turkey Cake and cakes decorated with florals and turkeys in warm fall colors. Any design not shown on the bakery's website is treated as a custom order.
Custom cake requests are handled through a quote form, which is an inquiry rather than a confirmed order. Most custom orders require at least two weeks' notice, and availability is limited from October through December because of the holiday season. At the time of writing, custom cakes were fully booked for the rest of the year, with the next available pickup date on January 11, 2027. Wedding cakes follow a separate process through the wedding department, which offers virtual consultations and its own questionnaire.
Cookies and dessert packages
The bakery assembles cookie and dessert packages for groups, boxed in quantities suited to the order size. Published package options include:
- 10 dozen made without nuts, for about 30 guests, at $80.00
- 10 dozen variety, for about 30 guests, at $99.00
- 10 dozen dessert, for about 30 guests, at $179.00
- 15 dozen dessert, for about 45 guests, at $257.00
- 30 dozen variety, for about 90 guests, at $299.00
- 50 dozen variety, for about 150 guests, at $615.00
The variety packages draw on items such as apricot bowls, brownie bites, buckeyes, chocolate tea, half-dipped chocolate chip, jelly tea, mini lady lox, nut bowls, pecan clouds, raspberry thumbprints, turtle thumbprints, white iced thumbprints and wreaths. The dessert packages add items such as bethels, caramel vanilla buttercream tart, raspberry buttercream tart, mini cherry cheesecake and mini yum yums. The nut-free package is produced in a bakery that uses tree nut and peanut ingredients.
Holiday and seasonal items
Thanksgiving brings a rotating lineup of specialties. Cream pies are available by pre-order only for pickup on the Wednesday before the holiday, in chocolate cream, coconut cream, chocolate peanut butter, banana cream and lemon meringue. Homestyle Nut Rolls, made with sweet dough and ground walnut filling, are sold in stores and by order through December 24; apricot and poppyseed fillings are available by pre-order only for pickup November 23–25. Pumpkin pie also features in the bakery's holiday giving program, Pies for a Purpose, which partners with the South Hills Interfaith Movement; the program donated more than 300 pumpkin pies to families in need the previous year.
Ordering and pickup
Orders can be placed through the online store or by phone with an order specialist, at least 72 hours in advance. Payment is required before pickup and recommended at the time of ordering to guarantee the order. Changes or cancellations on existing orders require 48 hours' notice, and custom requests may need up to 60 days' notice. Holiday deadlines apply: for Thanksgiving, all orders for November 23–25 had to be placed, changed or cancelled by November 19.
The in-store cases hold cookies, cakes and breakfast items for walk-in purchase. In-store products cannot be held for pickup and are sold on a first-come basis. The bakery also publishes cake ordering and cake care guides, color charts and a monthly newsletter covering products, holiday features and order deadlines.
Wedding department
The wedding department operates from the Brightwood Road address and is open Monday through Saturday, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. Couples can schedule a virtual wedding cake consultation and complete a questionnaire to begin planning; the department publishes wedding information, pricing, designs and a FAQ.
Cakes, cookies and wedding cakes
Photos
Select a photo to enlarge it.



