After walking through Edinburgh Castle, the downhill route across the Old Town invites a pause. Yet “a pub near the castle” does not describe one experience: some doors open onto the Royal Mile while others hide in a close or along the bend of West Bow. Choosing deliberately avoids a hurried round in the first visible bar. The Jolly Judge and The Bow Bar offer a comparison between a cider-and-beer refuge and a counter where whisky occupies more of the conversation.
Jolly Judge: finding the door in James Court
The Jolly Judge is at 7 James Court, down a close in the old town. It describes itself as independent, with low ceilings, corner seats and a range of beers, ciders and whiskies. CAMRA records awards for its cider and beer, a more concrete detail than calling it “the best” without explanation. It opens at noon each day, though closes earlier on Tuesday, Wednesday and Sunday. Space is limited: customers often value its cosy character, but a seat can be difficult to find at busy hours.
Bow Bar: ask before ordering
The Bow Bar stands at 80 West Bow on the street descending towards Grassmarket. Its website separates whisky and beer and lists cask and guest lines subject to change. Enter with a simple preference — a gentler malt, bitter ale or cider — and ask the staff for guidance rather than selecting by a familiar label. It opens from noon to midnight every day. Visitors praise the range and staff knowledge, while noting that the bar fills up and a long discussion about bottles can slow service.
A stop, not necessarily dinner
Both pubs fit a walk from the castle without public transport, but Old Town slopes and steps matter for anyone with limited mobility. Jolly Judge requires finding the right close; Bow Bar is lower down towards Grassmarket. Neither address should be offered as a guarantee of a full dinner. Some accounts mention snacks or savoury pies, but food available on the day needs checking. Read the closing time for your day, especially at Jolly Judge, and decide whether to eat first. Drinks other than alcohol are possible too: ask at the bar what is actually available.
For a tucked-away pause a few steps off the Royal Mile, James Court is the more direct choice. If you want to compare cask beers or explore whisky before continuing to Grassmarket, West Bow offers the more specialised counter. The best stop after the castle still leaves time to notice the neighbourhood and finish the walk without a rush.
Jolly Judge offers a corner below the Royal Mile; Bow Bar focuses on whisky and cask beer on the descent towards Grassmarket. Neither replaces a confirmed dinner plan.
Options to compare
These options relate to the question. Read each profile and check current details before deciding.
The Jolly Judge lies at the foot of James Court, one of the Old Town’s closes, a short way from Edinburgh Castle. The independent pub describes low ceilings, corner seats and a fire. It feels different from venues opening straight onto the Royal Mile: you must find the entrance to the close and go d
Beer and cider near the Castle
The Bow Bar occupies 80 West Bow, on the Old Town bend descending from the higher streets towards Grassmarket. Its identity lies in choosing a drink with care: the website has separate whisky and beer sections and lists changing cask and keg lines. This is not somewhere to seek a folkloric performan
Whisky and cask beer on West Bow
Sources & references
Sources for the information and reporting discussed in this guide.
-
Official website of The Jolly Judge ↗
Primary source
The Jolly Judge · Accessed October 10, 2026
Primary source for identity, concept, menu, and contact details.
-
Official website of The Jolly Judge ↗
Primary source
CAMRA · Accessed October 10, 2026
Primary source for identity, concept, menu, and contact details.
-
Official website of The Bow Bar ↗
Primary source
The Bow Bar · Accessed October 10, 2026
Primary source for identity, concept, menu, and contact details.
-
Official website of The Bow Bar ↗
Primary source
The Bow Bar · Accessed October 10, 2026
Primary source for identity, concept, menu, and contact details.
-
Official website ↗
Primary source
Edinburgh Castle · Accessed October 10, 2026
Primary source for identity, concept, menu, and contact details.
-
Valoración y experiencias de The Jolly Judge ↗
Secondary source
Restaurant Guru · Accessed October 10, 2026
Google 4.6/5 en 2772 reseñas de James Court 7; consultado 10/10/2026.
-
Valoración y testimonios de The Bow Bar ↗
Secondary source
Restaurant Guru · Accessed October 10, 2026
Google 4.6/5 en 2750 reseñas de West Bow 80; consultado 10/10/2026.