The Herringbone on the Waterfront, on West Water Street, occupies a 19th-century building associated with preserving herring. Today's cooking is contemporary American, with interpretations of Southern dishes, seasonal ingredients and wood-fired pizza. The interest lies in that reuse: a building connected with waterfront work now supports a different dining experience, without pretending to reproduce a historical menu.
The building does not replace the menu
Herringbone distinguishes lunch, dinner, brunch and dessert menus. Check the relevant service rather than assuming a dish is available at any hour. During a long weekend, that range makes it possible to give the restaurant a specific role, whether an arrival-night dinner or brunch. A waterfront address also does not guarantee the same view from every table; express a seating preference when arranging the visit.
Waterman’s Grill, on South Broad Street, retains another connection with seafood. The building housed Tynch & Toppin Fish Market in the 1960s and 1970s. Its present menu combines seafood, house-cut steaks and a raw bar. PBS North Carolina highlighted fried fish when featuring the restaurant in its August 2026 Edenton visit.
Here, organizing the evening works differently: Waterman’s does not accept reservations. Calling allows questions to be answered, but should not be described as securing a table. The restaurant publishes dinner service Monday through Saturday and closes Sunday. Allowing time for arrival is particularly useful for groups or anyone with a scheduled activity afterward.
A third table depends on the date
The Table at Inner Banks Inn connects dining with the inn and a former carriage house. Its seasonal approach and use of local products where available justify considering it for a more planned meal. However, the property announces limited dinner service. It should not be promised as an option every evening of the weekend.
Confirm whether the chosen dates offer dining-room dinner, an event or a service reserved for guests. Breakfast and food supplied to accommodation have their own arrangements. This precision does not lessen the restaurant's appeal; it makes the recommendation useful.
Herringbone offers contemporary cooking across several services; Waterman’s brings a seafood emphasis without reservations; The Table requires matching the experience to the calendar first. For three days in Edenton, resolving those differences is part of eating well, and avoids adding a fourth restaurant merely to lengthen the selection.
Sources
- The Herringbone On The Waterfront
- About Waterman's Grill — Edenton, NC
- A Weekend in Edenton | North Carolina Weekend
- Menu — Waterman's Grill, Edenton, NC
- table
Places in this article
Restaurants to compare
These restaurants match the question. Check menus, prices and recent reviews before visiting.
A contemporary American waterfront restaurant in a former 19th-century herring icehouse. Southern influences, seasonal ingredients and wood-fired pizza appear across distinct lunch, dinner and brunch menus.
A South Broad Street restaurant with seafood, house-cut steaks and a raw bar in a former fish-market building. Dinner runs Monday through Saturday, and the restaurant explicitly does not accept reservations.
Inner Banks Inn’s dining project occupies a former carriage house and emphasizes seasonal sourcing. Dinner availability is limited, with dining-room service, events and guest-only food arrangements requiring separate confirmation.
Sources & references
Sources for the information and reporting discussed in this guide.
-
The Herringbone On The Waterfront ↗
Primary source
the-herringbone.com · Accessed September 26, 2026
MASKAY NC 2026 · shared evidence for ES and EN; documentary verification.
-
Waterman's Grill — Edenton, NC ↗
Primary source
www.watermansgrill.com · Accessed September 26, 2026
MASKAY NC 2026 · shared evidence for ES and EN; documentary verification.
-
About Waterman's Grill — Edenton, NC ↗
Primary source
www.watermansgrill.com · Accessed September 26, 2026
MASKAY NC 2026 · shared evidence for ES and EN; documentary verification.
-
Menu — Waterman's Grill, Edenton, NC ↗
Primary source
www.watermansgrill.com · Accessed September 26, 2026
MASKAY NC 2026 · shared evidence for ES and EN; documentary verification.
-
table ↗
Primary source
www.innerbanksinn.com · Accessed September 26, 2026
MASKAY NC 2026 · shared evidence for ES and EN; documentary verification.
-
inner-banks ↗
Primary source
www.innerbanksinn.com · Accessed September 26, 2026
MASKAY NC 2026 · shared evidence for ES and EN; documentary verification.
-
edenton-dining ↗
Primary source
visitedenton.com · Accessed September 26, 2026
MASKAY NC 2026 · shared evidence for ES and EN; documentary verification.
-
Plan Your Visit | NC Historic Sites ↗
Primary source
historicsites.nc.gov · Accessed September 26, 2026
MASKAY NC 2026 · shared evidence for ES and EN; documentary verification.
-
History & Tours | Cupola House and Gardens ↗
Primary source
cupolahouse.org · Accessed September 26, 2026
MASKAY NC 2026 · shared evidence for ES and EN; documentary verification.
-
Contact | Edenton Historic Tours at Cupola House and Gardens ↗
Primary source
cupolahouse.org · Accessed September 26, 2026
MASKAY NC 2026 · shared evidence for ES and EN; documentary verification.
-
About Us - Edenton Cotton Mill Museum of History ↗
Primary source
www.millvillagemuseum.org · Accessed September 26, 2026
MASKAY NC 2026 · shared evidence for ES and EN; documentary verification.
-
Edenton Historical Commission – The Edenton Historical Commission is housed in the Penelope Barker Welcome Center, in the heart of Edenton, NC. ↗
Primary source
ehcnc.org · Accessed September 26, 2026
MASKAY NC 2026 · shared evidence for ES and EN; documentary verification.
-
A Weekend in Edenton | North Carolina Weekend ↗
Secondary source
www.pbsnc.org · Accessed September 26, 2026
MASKAY NC 2026 · shared evidence for ES and EN; documentary verification.